Report of the Human Rights Defender on the activities of the National Preventive Mechanism in Poland in 2013
CCTV cameras, although the sobering-up station202 has an outpatient department and a doctor’s surgery. The medical confidentiality is also breached when
a Police officer is present during medical examination.203 The instructions on
treatment of patients in one of the visited stations204 state that “the supervisor
should each time participate and, if necessary, assist the doctor in examining an
intoxicated person and during other medical procedures on that person”. This provision raised concerns of the employees of the Mechanism. The representatives of
the National Preventive Mechanism are of the opinion that the presence of a nonmedical officer during the provision of health care services to patients should be
exceptional and take place only when it is required to ensure safety of the person
providing health care services and is explicitly requested by the medical personnel. Such a view was expressed by CPT in its 12th General Report, stating that all
medical examinations must be conducted out of the hearing and out of the sight of
non-medical personnel (§ 42 in [CPT/Inf (2002)15]).
5.3.5. Right to intimacy
The visits of the representatives of the NPM reveal that in numerous stations
the right to intimacy of persons brought to sober up is violated.
5.3.6. Living conditions
As regards the living conditions, the representatives of the NPM verify whether
the standards observed in the sobering-up stations comply with the legislation in force.
During the inspection of the stations, the employees of the Mechanism pay particular
attention on adjustment of the buildings to the needs of persons with disabilities.
A frequently encountered problem by the representatives of the NPM during the visits is the non-adjustment of the visited stations to the needs of persons
with disabilities.205 The lack of appropriate infrastructure concerned the lack of
handgrips and rails enabling the persons on wheelchairs to use the toilets and the
placement of the button of the call system too high, out of reach of such persons.
Sobering-up Station in Poznań.
Sobering-up Station in Poznań.
204
Sobering-up Station in Bytom.
205
Sobering-up Station in Koszalin, Sobering-up Station in Poznań.
202
203
64
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents