CHAPTER 5
VIEWS AND PERSPECTIVES
OF CHILDREN DEPRIVED OF LIBERTY
b. Punishment
Violence and other punishments were regularly experienced, which not only involved other
children, but also the police and security staff.
‘There were fights all day, every day. It was too hard. They were fighting with others from
day to night for the bed, for the food, for the toilet’. (M/19/3:WEOG)
‘One could be beaten when he commits mistakes’. (M/14-17/1:WEOG)
‘When a minor misbehaves towards his friends instead of offering him an educational
sanction, he is sent to the convicts’ building where the serious criminal offenders are
located’. (M/15-18/1:AFG)
One young man described an incident of chemical restraint when he was being unruly.
‘I was shouting for my rights and they thought I had epilepsy. They gave me medical
treatment, but I threw the pills away’. (M/22/3:WEOG)
Some children viewed the use of proportionate restraint as acceptable when children are
fighting, to control unruly behaviour and to prevent injury: ‘Restraint should be allowed for
safety of the staff’ (M/16-17/1:WEOG). Strip searches, however, were perceived by one boy as
problematic, especially if used for no apparent reason, for example if a boy had no record
of drug use (M/16/1:WEOG).
Several children mentioned suffering physical and verbal abuse during arrest and detention.
Boys were more likely to describe physical brutality, while girls thought the police were
disrespectful and used sexualised language towards them. Some girls also described being
physically assaulted.
‘I would hear people screaming including a minor who had tried to escape they were
put in isolation and beaten as repercussion’. (M/22/3:WEOG)
‘They asked me why I ran away from home. When I didn’t answer, why did he slap me?’
(F/10-18/1:APG)
The children explained that experiencing disrespectful treatment from staff could increase
the chances of riots, retaliation and unrest.
96
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents