National Preventive Mechanism
Need for more space
The fact that patients will still be housed in two six-bed rooms until the
station is expanded is problematic from a human rights perspective. The
team regrets this situation. All sides agree that improving the situation as
quickly as possible is desirable. As a first step, partitions were set up between
the beds to protect the privacy of the patients.
Bed must be kept free
With respect to the demand to reduce occupancy, the Sigmund Freud Regional
Neurological and Psychiatric Hospital stated that the number of patients
in a room could be reduced, which would mean the loss of at least four
nursing positions. Until the completion of the structural expansion, they are
attempting to compensate for the deficit by keeping two beds in the six-bed
rooms free for patients whose placement is interrupted. However, there is an
obligation to offer these patients a bed again, if necessary. Since the goal is to
provide the patients with “their own” bed again, the number of beds actually
set up cannot be reduced at the present time.
CPT also recommends
single-patient rooms
The Federal Ministry of Justice regards this compromise with the standard
of the CPT to be acceptable considering the renovation concept that is
already in existence. It is true that the CPT did not comment on the living
conditions at the Sigmund Freud Hospital during its last visit in February
2009. However, the CPT has repeatedly recommended the creation of a
therapeutic environment with single rooms and small placement units (most
recently after reviewing a forensic psychiatry station at a Lisbon hospital in
July 2012, CPT/Inf [2013] 4).
In light of this, the NPM welcomes the efforts of the Federal Ministry of Justice
to encourage the competent legal entity to quickly expand the forensic station
at the Sigmund Freud Regional Neurological and Psychiatric Hospital.
¾¾ If six-person rooms cannot be separated structurally, setting up mobile
partitions can increase privacy.
2.5.6 Deficits with respect to restraints – forensic department of the Hall
Regional Hospital
Tied down and left
alone
158
In the course of a visit to the forensic department of the Hall Regional
Hospital, the commission found that a female patient had been restrained
for over 14 hours. Thereupon, the commission inspected the nursing
documentation. It was their conclusion that the documentation did not
show that the nursing staff was continuously present during the restraint of
the patient. This conclusion was supported by the fact that the patient had
wet the bed repeatedly during the period of restraint and, according to her
own statement, had to lie in the urine-soaked bed for about 30 minutes. The
delegation also found that no mitigating measures had been documented.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents