The architectural design of premises in which persons deprived of liberty live or pass
through – secure facilities of courts, police stations and gendarmeries, secure rooms of
general hospitals, intensive treatment rooms in psychiatric hospitals, new arrival and
punishment wings in prisons – needs to reconcile security requirements with those of the
captives being able to conduct their rudimentary activities and the guards being able to carry
out the procedural acts in compliance with the rights of dignity, privacy and confidentiality.
1.2.1 Maintaining Bodily Hygiene
The material conditions of imprisonment do not always enable captives to
meet their basic requirements with regard to hygiene under conditions
which protect their dignity, because the necessary premises – shower rooms,
bathrooms – are not accessible to them or because the conditions of access
and use thereof are such that they intrinsically infringe their privacy and
dignity.
Ease of Access to Bathrooms
Apart from the fact that a certain number of them are collective, hospital rooms only rarely
contain full bathroom facilities. The inspectors noted that in many situations provision was made
for nothing more than a sink, which was not always concealed by a screen. In certain rooms,
patients only have slop pails at their disposal.
Seclusion rooms – whether of recent or old design – often do not have bathroom
facilities, and toilets in particular. The latter are replaced by bedpans, urinals or pails etc. In one
recent institution, the doctors had criticised the absence of direct access between the room and
shower room, for which provision had not been made: according to them, apart from infringing
upon the patient’s dignity, slop pails could present a danger for the latter – there had been an
occurrence of a patient tripping over the pail in the night – and for the medical staff – another
patient had thrown the pail and its contents at a member of staff.
Police custody cells are not all equipped with toilets. In this situation captive
persons have to ask to be able to go out in order to use the toilets, which
are sometimes located outside of the secure zone. When there are bathroom
facilities inside the cells, they often consist of basins level with the floor,
without any pan, particularly unsuitable for women and persons with
restricted mobility.
In any case, collective cells are never equipped with toilets. Similarly, neither are court jails
(individual cells and collective cells) always equipped with bathroom facilities and a water tap. It
was also noted in the accommodation areas of certain detention centres for illegal immigrants,
that the detainees’ rooms did not contain a separate bathroom area.
Numerous court jails are located in the basement, comprising individual cells and
collective cell. In fact, characteristic features of the latter are the absence of any view of the
exterior, as well as the absence of ventilation, heating and any facilities for washing.
Although prison cells are always equipped with a toilet and sink, which are
essential for confinement, in certain prisons, the toilet bowl is placed in a
corner of the cell, devoid of any partition.
When partitions are present, they are often inadequate or partial. In the oldest
institutions, the inspectors ascertained that in some cases the partitions do not go up to the
ceiling, in others sheets or curtains serve as doors, while elsewhere (due to poorly-designed
partitioning) the bathroom surface area is so narrow that the doors, or whatever serves in place
of the latter – in most cases double doors –, have to be left open when the facilities are being
135
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents