> 1 OPJ per
office
yes
yes
no
yes
yes
yes (6)
yes
Designated
PC officer
yes
yes
yes
yes
NP
NP
NP
Except in cells designed for minors.
No blankets available.
Blankets no longer available in this police station at the time of the inspection.
Contradictory testimonies: according to the officers blankets were given to persons in police custody; when
questioned, the latter asserted that no blankets had been given to them.
“Intermediate” search very common, as explained in note (3) of the previous table.
In ten offices out of thirteen, there were at least two OPJs.
A number of remarks are once again necessary with regard to these tables of a more
qualitative character.
Several additional criteria have been deliberately singled out with regard to different
elements.
a/ The first of these concerns available space. The number of cells and rooms for
sobering-up was noted. In police stations of recent construction, no distinction is any longer
made between the two. Persons in a state of public and manifest drunkenness taken to the police
station (after a ritual visit to the hospital for the issuing of a certificate of refusal of
hospitalisation) are therefore placed in cells also used for police custody. This confusion appears
logical, since cells in these police stations are henceforth equipped with toilet bowls, which were
previously reserved to rooms for sobering-up alone: it was probably considered that since the
facilities are identical, there was no longer any reason for the distinction; this is even likely to
simplify management, since drunken persons suspected of having committed crimes, initially left
to sober up, may be placed in police custody after having regained their sobriety, without any
need to change the place in which they are accommodated. However, this confusion might be
regretted at the legal level: placement for sobering up is an administrative police measure; police
custody takes place within the framework of law-enforcement operations aimed at the pursuit of
offenders and criminals.
The absence of specific rooms for sobering-up is therefore characteristic of
the most recent police stations.
In principle, collective cells are used when all of the individual cells are occupied. This
distinction is also dependent upon the age of the police station concerned. The oldest stations
only possess collective cells, which are few in number. The most recent stations have a majority
of individual cells and sometimes, as in the case of Saint-Quentin and Vénissieux, do not possess
any collective cells at all. However, placement in either type of cell may depend upon other
factors, such as the sex of the persons in police custody, or the prevention of communication
between persons charged in the same case.
In general, minors are placed in separate cells from adults. However, in reality, the cells
for minors mentioned in the above tables are not those in which children are actually placed (in
principle next to the guard-room), but merely cells originally designed to be occupied exclusively
by minors. Less than a third of the police stations and headquarters listed here possess such cells.
Moreover, they do not possess any specific facilities and may even be less well-equipped than
others (Pointe-à-Pitre). This might be regretted.
36
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents