HASSAN v. THE UNITED KINGDOM – JUDGMENT
5
A. The invasion of Iraq
9. On 20 March 2003 a coalition of armed forces under unified
command, led by the United States of America with a large force from the
United Kingdom and small contingents from Australia, Denmark and
Poland, commenced the invasion of Iraq from their assembly point across
the border with Kuwait. By 5 April 2003 British forces had captured Basrah
and by 9 April 2003 United States troops had gained control of Baghdad.
Major combat operations in Iraq were declared complete on 1 May 2003.
B. The capture of the applicant’s brother by British forces
10. Prior to the invasion, the applicant was a general manager in the
national secretariat of the Ba’ath Party and a general in the Al-Quds Army,
the army of the Ba’ath Party. He lived in Umm Qasr, a port city in the
region of Basrah, near the border with Kuwait and about 50 kilometres from
Al-Basrah (Basrah City). After the British army entered into occupation of
Basrah, they started arresting high ranking members of the Ba’ath Party.
Other Ba’ath Party members were killed by Iraqi militia. The applicant and
his family therefore went into hiding, leaving the applicant’s brother,
Tarek Resaan Hassan (henceforth, “Tarek Hassan”), and his cousin to
protect the family home.
11. According to information given by the Government, members of a
British army unit, the 1st Battalion The Black Watch, went to the applicant’s
house early in the morning of 23 April 2003, hoping to arrest him. The
applicant was not there, but the British forces encountered Tarek Hassan,
who was described in the contemporaneous report drawn up by the arresting
unit (“the battalion record”) as a “gunman”, found on the roof of the house
with an AK-47 machine gun. The battalion record indicated that the
“gunman” identified himself as the brother of the applicant and that he was
arrested at approximately 6.30 a.m. It further indicated that the house was
found by the arresting soldiers to contain other firearms and a number of
documents of intelligence value, related to local membership of the Ba’ath
Party and the Al-Quds Army.
12. According to a statement made by the applicant and dated
30 November 2006, Tarek Hassan was arrested by British troops on
22 April 2003, in the applicant’s absence. According to this statement,
“When my sisters approached the British military authority they were told
that I had to surrender myself to them before they would release my
brother”. In a later statement, dated 12 September 2008, the applicant did
not mention his sisters but instead stated that he asked his friend, Saeed
Teryag, and his neighbour Haj Salem, to ask British forces for information
about Tarek Hassan. The applicant asked these friends because he could
trust them; Haj Salem was a respected businessman and Saeed Teryag had