the definition of “detention places” in OPCAT by presenting a closed
exhaustive list of categories of institutions was deemed to be improper. Such an
approach would have inevitably resulted in the creation of a visit system with a too
restricted and too restrictive scope of application. However, certain categories fall
under the definition of “detention places” provided by OPCAT and could be
expressed through a non-exhaustive definition in national legislation, for clarity
reasons, such as: • police departments; • preventive arrest; • prisons; • juvenile
detention centres;• border police and transit areas at border crossing points, harbours
and international airports; • detention centres for immigrants and asylum applicants; •
psychiatric institutions; • detention centres under military jurisdiction; • means of
transport for the transfer of prisoners.
Additionally to these quite obvious categories, according to article 4, NPM
should have access to any other place where someone can be kept against his/her
own will, even indirectly connected to public authority.
Two key phrases in the definition of “detention place” in the meaning of
article 4 describe the nature of this connection: • “under its jurisdiction and control”;
• “by virtue of an order issued by a public authority or upon its request or with its
consent or approval” (regarding the means by which a person is or can be kept in a
detention place).
SPT considers that, regarding the implementation of this definition in
operational practice, it would be desirable “to provide a more extended
interpretation to this definition, so as to increase the impact of the preventive
activities of NPMs”. “Any place where a person is deprived from freedom (i.e.
s/he is not free to leave it at his/her own will) or where (...) a person could be
deprived from freedom, s/he should fall under the jurisdiction of the OPCAT
mandate if it is a situation where the state exercises or could exercise a
regulatory function”.
Based on art. 34 of Law no. 35/1997 on the organization and operation of
the People’s Advocate Institution, republished: a detention place is any place
where persons are deprived from freedom based on a decision of an authority,
upon its request or with its explicit or tacit approval.
34
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents