Other Crowd Control
7.5
BARBED OR RAZOR WIRE BARRIERS OR
FENCES
Key Technical
Features
Human Rights
Concerns
Fencing or other type of barrier, which has sharp wire fixed
perpendicular to the main body. The barrier is often coiled for
transport, and can then be deployed quickly.
The use of barriers that have an offensive function beyond the primary
purpose of restricting access or movement, such as barbed wire, razor
wire, or any other spiked barrier, is disproportionate and unnecessary
in a crowd control setting, and should be prohibited.
This use of type of barrier as a form of crowd control creates an
ongoing, indiscriminate, and uncontrollable risk of unintentional or
disproportionate injury.
Statements and
Standards from
Human Rights Bodies
OHCHR: “Physical barriers should never be such as to pose a risk to
safety. Barbed wire, razor wire or other spiked barriers typically create
an undue risk of injury to participants in an assembly. Where a barrier
is needed, safer alternatives should be employed”. 126
Examples of Existing
Controls
The EU may prohibit the export of this equipment under its sanction
regime when the objective of the sanctions is to prevent the export of
equipment that might be used for internal repression in the destination
state.
Manufacture should be controlled.
Proposed Control
Trade and transfer should be controlled.
Prohibited for use in crowd control.
126
OHCHR, UN Human Rights Guidance on Less-Lethal Weapons in Law Enforcement, 2020, para. 6.3.5.
125
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents