Gender and SSR Toolkit
Support for improving the treatment of women and other
vulnerable groups in prison may be more easily obtained
than support for reform more generally. The government
should produce information about women and children in
prison that is easily accessible and not buried at the back
of long reports. By involving civil society groups
concerned with women and children and ensuring that
prisons cooperate with such groups by giving them such
access, various activities can be generated that can build
public support.
5
Integrating gender into
penal reform in specific
contexts
5.1 Post-conflict countries
■
!
■
Background
States emerging from a period of conflict or internal
turmoil present particular penal reform challenges.
Against a background of many pressing priorities, such
as rebuilding the infrastructure and re-establishing basic
institutions, rebuilding a penal system is sometimes seen
as a low priority. From the outset, it is important that the
relevant state administrative body accepts the need for
detention facilities to be provided and run, and allocates
sufficient resources for these purposes.
■
■
Challenges and opportunities for integrating gender
Rebuilding a penal system is very complex. Major
considerations are:
■
■
■
The existing local situation regarding prisons needs to
be understood. Prisons may have very bad
associations for the population of the country:
detention without trial, rape, torture and execution.
Rebuilding may be an opportunity to start with a clean
slate and establish a system that will be less abusive,
more gender responsive and more trusted by the
people.
The original prison system may have been
dysfunctional or completely out of accord with the rule
of law and gender equality. It may have been run by the
police or the military, contrary to good human rights
practice. If so, a different model of imprisonment needs
to be created, but there is a danger that models from
outside the country and inappropriate to its
circumstances will be imported. A prison system must
be re-established in a manner sensitive to the cultural
and social environment, whilst also making efforts to
introduce ideas such as better treatment for women
and the employment of women staff.
If a pre-conflict public prison service still exists and can
be re-established quickly, the post-conflict environment
may provide an opportunity to vet staff that have been
involved in abuses and retrain other staff in a human
rights approach that is gender sensitive.
14
■
■
■
Before the conflict, there will have been a prison law in
force but it may have been inadequate, out of date and
disregarded because of its obsolescence. Yet, any
place of detention set up in a post-conflict international
intervention must be administered according to law,
since the remit of the intervention is to assist in reestablishing a law-bound state. In the transitional
period in 1999, the International Force for East Timor
established a rudimentary prison law based on
international standards which ensured no
discrimination, regular visits by independent outsiders,
norms for searching detainees, accommodation,
hygiene, food, facilities for making purchases,
exercise, the practice of religion and access to medical
treatment.68 Starting prison reconstruction with a
system that respects human rights and ensures no
discrimination provides a good basis for the eventual
construction of a gender-responsive penal system.
Tips
In post-conflict situations, understanding the different
needs and roles of men and women is particularly
important, especially if sexual violence was used in the
conflict. Foreign forces and international bodies
coming into a post-conflict situation to rebuild a prison
system will need considerable training in cultural
awareness and gender sensitivity.
Handover from the police and the military to a civilian
prison service as soon as possible.
When rebuilding a system that existed before the
conflict, consider working with more junior members of
staff who will have had less responsibility for past
abuses and are more likely to be receptive to a human
rights based, gender-responsive approach.
Where prison staff from other states are brought in to
manage prisons in the transitional phase, it is important
to ensure that the men and women selected have
experience in dealing with female and young prisoners.
Recruiters should look for cultural sensitivity and good
communication and interpersonal skills, exemplary
personal history and gender sensitivity.
Where visits to other countries are part of penal staff
training, it is important that it includes exposure to good
practice in gender matters and meetings not only with
officials but also with civil society groups concerned
with gender issues.
Ensure that accurate information about the prisons, the
regime and the treatment is in the public domain, so
that rumours related to alleged ill-treatment and sexual
and other abuse can be quashed. Family visits are
important, not only for the families involved, but so that
families can dispel any rumours concerning alleged illtreatment.
5.2 Transitional countries in Eastern
Europe and Central Asia
The countries of Central Asia and Eastern Europe (called
transitional countries after 1989 as they were deemed to
be in transition to a new form of government) are
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents