2.6.2.3
Inadequate partitioning of toilet areas in
cells for multiple inmates
In the course of their visits to the Salzburg police detention centre, the
commission criticised the fact that the toilet area in two-person cells is
only separated from the rest of the cell by a partition so that the toilet
area can be seen from the side. The commission found the partial
walling off of toilet areas (without doors) to be problematic since a
prisoner may be observed by a fellow prisoner or a guard while
relieving himself. This would constitute a violation of the right of
privacy.
Two-person cells in the
Salzburg police
detention centre
In this regard, the Federal Ministry of the Interior stated that renovating
the 43 cells at the Salzburg police detention centre (by building walls,
installing doors and then installing flooring and painting each cell) is
not feasible under the budget. If a prisoner believes that his privacy is
being invaded, he can make an express request to use a two-person
cell alone – if there is free capacity. The Federal Ministry of the Interior
stressed that, in general, police detention centres always respect a
prisoner’s desire to use a cell for multiple inmates alone, as long as
the number of persons housed at the Salzburg police detention centre
permits and there are no countervailing concerns.
Also at the Steyr police detention centre, the commission found that
the toilet in a cell occupied by six prisoners serving an administrative
penalty was not walled in on all sides at the time of the visit. Moreover,
the prisoners’ toilet in the eight-person cell in the second upper floor is
walled in all directions and has a door but it is open at the top. It is
humiliating and degrading for prisoners to have to relieve themselves
in such a way that their fellow prisoners are directly confronted with
smells and/or noises. Therefore, the NPM asked the Federal Ministry
of the Interior to take the necessary structural measures as quickly as
possible to separate the toilet from the rest of the cell at the top as
well.
The Federal Ministry of the Interior rejected the suggestion of the NPM
to extend the toilet wall to reach the ceiling. On one hand, such a
structural change would prevent any ventilation of the toilet area. On
the other hand, extending the wall would be too expensive due to the
historic construction of the ceilings at the Steyr police detention centre.
Moreover, the space available at the Steyr police detention centres
does not permit the cell in question to be occupied by one person.
However, the Steyr police detention centre has given its assurance that
the cell will only be occupied by a maximum of six persons in the
future. Moreover, upon request, a person may, if there are adequate
resources, be moved to a single cell or given sole use of a cell for
multiple inmates. If a prisoner asks to be alone in a cell and an
appropriate inmate cell is free, the request will be granted. The overall
renovation of the Linz police detention centre is of particular interest
123
Eight-person cell at the
Steyr police detention
centre
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents