42 LAW-ENFORCEMENT EQUIPMENT IN CENTRAL ASIA AND THE SOUTH CAUCASUS
was a commitment to increase security cooperation between China and
Uzbekistan, with particular reference to anti-terrorism.105
The USA has been particularly active in providing training in equipment and
techniques in Central Asia. Following deadly clashes during the disputed
presidential elections in Armenia, the USA announced that it would be launching
a programme of training on crowd-control techniques for the Armenian riot
police.106 The US Marine Corps also organizes an annual ‘Non-Lethal Weapons
Executive Seminar’, in which US military personnel train regional participants in
the use of a range of less-lethal weapon systems and tactics. Mongolia has hosted
the event three times, in 2007, 2010 and 2013. It is unclear whether equipment is
donated by the US military to participants or hosts of the event, although it
seems likely that there are follow-up transfers, given that training is afforded on
different devices. At the 2013 event in Mongolia, representatives from 22 nations
were shown a range of technologies and techniques, including demonstrations of
the Taser X26 projectile electric-shock system, and participated in a pepperspray qualification course.107
An area that requires significant scrutiny is the provision of training services
by equipment suppliers. Care should be taken that the techniques being taught by
private companies do not breach national or international best-practice standards
for the use of force. The authors are aware of companies providing police and
security equipment in the region as part of a training package whose techniques
appear to be similar to those described by the CPT as being of concern. A video
by the Czech-based company Euro Security Products shows a 2013 training
session for Georgian police personnel.108 The techniques demonstrated include
the use of batons to facilitate a neck hold, a technique described by the CPT as
having the potential to cause serious injury that should therefore not be used.109
Monitors should therefore ensure that all training is carried out by suitably
qualified personnel and that, where companies have provided equipment, any
training services also provided are subject to independent scrutiny and oversight
and are in line with international standards. They should also ascertain what
guidelines for use the manufacturers of specific equipment provide and ensure
that those guidelines are in line with international standards.
105 ‘China, Uzbekistan vow tighter security cooperation’, 15 Oct. 2014, <http://www.iteuzbekistan.uz/vis/caips/eng/press/news.php?ELEMENT_ID=12072>.
106
‘Armenian riot police to get US training’, Asbarez.com, 22 Dec. 2009,
<http://asbarez.com/75259/armenian-riot-police-to-get-u-s-training/>.
107 Eberle, B., ‘Non-lethal weapons leadership seminar begins, field training ends, [images]’, Defense
Video and Imagery Distribution System, 26 Aug. 2013, <http://www.dvidshub.net/image/1003495/nonlethal-weapons-leadership-seminar-begins-field-training-ends#.VIbjp8khHRs>. A 2014 exercise known
as Khaan Quest, also held in Mongolia, involved joint military exercises between the USA and a range
of regional participants for soldiers preparing for international peacekeeping missions, and included riotcontrol training. Regional observers included Russia, Kazakhstan and Tajikistan. ‘US Military Conducts
Exercises in Mongolia’, Eurasianet.org, <http://www.eurasianet.org/node/68881>.
108 Euro Security products, ‘Georgia Training Mission’, <http://www.euro-security.info/eurosecurity.info/_video/Georgia_training_mission_ESP.mp4>.
109 CPT, Report to the Slovenia Government on the Visit to Slovenia carried out by the European
Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT)
from 31 January to 8 February 2006, CPT/Inf (2008) 7, <http://www.cpt.coe.int/documents/svn/200807-inf-eng.htm>.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents