EN_CPT_AR.book Page 9 Monday, October 25, 2010 5:14 PM
Activities during the period 1 August 2009 to 31 July 2010
In their response, the Czech authorities state that they do not share the CPT’s
view that surgical castration of detained sex offenders amounts to degrading
treatment. Nevertheless, they point out that the application of this intervention visà-vis sex offenders is the subject of ongoing discussions by various advisory bodies
to the Government. Further, to assist the process of reflection, an expert study is
being prepared by the Ministry of Health in collaboration with the Government
Commissioner for Human Rights. In addition to examining the medical, ethical and
legal aspects of the application of surgical castration in relation to sex offenders, the
study will include a comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of alternative
methods for treating sex offenders.
The Czech authorities also refer in their response to measures taken to ensure
that CPT visiting delegations have unrestricted access to medical records.
7.
The ad hoc visit to Italy in June 2010 was in part of a follow-up nature, namely
to review steps taken to implement recommendations aimed at improving the
provision of health care in prisons which were made by the CPT in the report on its
2008 periodic visit. Particular attention was given to the effect of the recent transfer
of responsibility for prison health care from the Prison Administration to the
Regional Health Services.
The CPT’s delegation also examined the action taken in response to the
increased number of suicides and acts of self-harm in prison. Further, against the
backdrop of some recent and well-known cases, the delegation considered the
system in place to investigate allegations of ill-treatment of persons deprived of their
liberty.
8.
The purpose of the ad hoc visit to Latvia in December 2009 was to review
progress as regards the treatment and conditions of detention of prisoners, in the
light of the recommendations made by the CPT after its 2007 periodic visit. In the
report on the 2007 visit, the Committee expressed serious concern about the
situation found at Jēkabpils Prison (allegations of severe ill-treatment by prison
officers, widespread violence among prisoners, poor conditions of detention). Major
shortcomings were also found as regards the conditions of detention of prisoners
sentenced to life imprisonment.
During the 2009 visit, the CPT’s delegation re-examined the situation at
Jēkabpils Prison. It also returned to the units for life-sentenced prisoners at
Daugavgrīvas and Jelgava Prisons, which continued to hold all of the country’s male
lifers.
9