21
Selected topics from 2018
Coercive measures still widely used in the mental
healthcare services
The UN Committee against Torture also raised several
problematic issues relating to the mental healthcare
services. The extent of the use of coercive measures
and other means of force gave particular cause for
concern. It was pointed out that forced medication
constituted a risk of lasting and irreversible harm.
The committee also criticised the lack of attempts
at using less invasive measures before forced treatment was initiated, and that the authorities lacked
an overview and control when electroconvulsive
therapy (ECT) was administered without consent. The
committee recommended a number of measures,
including that the authorities
››ensure that the patients’ dignity is preserved
and that attempts at eliminating unlawful use
of force be continued, including by considering
further legislative amendments
››establish efficient procedural safeguards for
the patients, including by ensuring effective
complaint mechanisms
››ensure clear and detailed rules for the use of
coercive measures, including restraint beds, with
a view to achieving a significant reduction in
both scope and duration
››consider eliminating forced treatment with
intrusive and irreversible effects, such as ECT
››ensure reparation and rehabilitation for persons
subjected to arbitrary psychiatric treatment
against their will, without procedural safeguards
and independent supervision
The UN Human Rights Committee also expressed
concern about the use of force in the mental healthcare services in its observations regarding Norway.5
5 See note above, paragraph 22–23.
Criticism of the conditions at Trandum
The committee was concerned about the treatment of
detainees at the police immigration detention centre
at Trandum. The committee referred among other
things to the use of body searches that the detainees
experienced as humiliating. The lack of routine
medical examinations on arrival was problematised,
and many municipalities’ long waiting times and lack
of willingness to offer health services to this group of
people was considered particularly worrying. It could
in this respect become impossible to identify signs of
torture and provide the necessary treatment to those
concerned. The committee recommended that the
authorities ensure that persons detained at Trandum
receive treatment in accordance with international
standards, including that
››the authorities ensure full protection against
future persecution or torture
››detainees promptly receive an offer of a medical
examination on arrival at the detention centre
››procedures be established to identify victims of
torture and to assess the risk of torture in cases
of deportation
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents