Bodily Hygiene
It appears important to promote the restoration of a person’s positive image by daily
bodily rituals. In some units, aesthetic care activities are organised by nursing auxiliaries.
Respect for personal autonomy should also lead to adaptation of the hours of access to
showers to the patient’s state. In numerous institutions visited, patients are not authorised to take
showers in the afternoon and evening. Although restrictions may legitimately be imposed in
order to enable proper organisation of the department – in particular, at the time of distribution
of meals –, it is not proper to refuse a patient a shower for the sole reason that “their access is no
longer authorised after 11 a.m.”. Furthermore, the inspectors ascertained that baths are
underused in the units and that patients who ask to have a bath are rarely heard.
The CGLPL recommends that hours of access to showers should be extended and adapted
to the patients’ state.
Certain public mental health institutions have a hairdressing salon and/or get a local
hairdresser to come in return for payment. However, in one of the latter institutions it was
pointed out that the haircuts offered – clippers for all men and bobs for all women – protected
“neither personal dignity, nor self-esteem”; the staff therefore preferred escorted outings to a
hairdresser in the town. However, visits to hairdressers are only possible when the hospital is not
too far from a town centre; in certain cases, hairdressers do not come to the institution and
outings to the town are rare, due to the location of the institution and its staff requirements.
The CGLPL considers that pleasure and well-being are important elements with regard to
learning to become autonomous or recovering one’s autonomy. Any initiative that makes it
possible to promote these elements should therefore be encouraged.
Showing Respect for Persons
Although the inspectors ascertained that hospital teams are very receptive to the question
of human dignity, the fact remains that psychiatric hospitals, like any closed institution, are not
exempt from various different forms of abuse of power.
One example of a measure violating dignity was brought to light at the time of a visit to a
UMD: the inspectors ascertained that patients only had a spoon with which to eat the whole of
their meals, obliging them in most cases to use their hands. In another institution of the same
type, serious violations of dignity were observed, such as the obligation placed upon patients to
undress in the corridors before going to bed. These measures, which are generally justified by
reasons of protection of the person (prevention of suicide in particular), as well as security with
regard to possible attacks, cannot legitimise the harm thus inflicted on patients’ self-esteem.
Furthermore, it is sometimes normal practice to address patients using the
familiar “tu” form, reinforcing feelings of being treated like a child and loss
of autonomy.
The CGLPL regularly receives letters from patients reporting that they feel belittled or
threatened – with being placed in seclusion rooms in particular – if they do not show themselves
to be sufficiently “docile” towards medical staff. Respect for the dignity of persons hospitalised
without their consent means taking patients’ feelings of humiliation into consideration, beyond
the objective reality of the situation.
The CGLPL recalls that personal dignity is intimately linked to the notion of respect. It
recommends that the formal “vous” form should be used for clearer relations between
medical staff and patients and with a view to their readjustment to life in society.
134
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents