A/HRC/19/61/Add.1
40. Also in the context of these demonstrations, the Special Rapporteur heard direct
victim testimony about the arbitrary arrest and beatings of a group of young people that
included more than 20 minors. Together with about 46 adults, they were arbitrarily detained
and taken to a detention centre without any access to a lawyer or notification to their
families; they were set free at 4 a.m. in one of the most dangerous areas of Tunis. During
about 12 hours of detention, detention officers forced them to kneel and remain in
uncomfortable positions. The forensic examination of one of the young men was consistent
with the allegation of being beaten by several policemen.
3.
Conditions in places of detention
(a)
Prisons
41. The Special Rapporteur received reports that, with an average prison population of
26,000 prisoners,6 prisons and other places of detention have been heavily overcrowded.
While the recent general amnesty, conditional releases and a presidential pardon
considerably reduced the size of the prison population, the destruction of several prisons
during the revolution has reportedly contributed to continued overcrowding.
42. The Special Rapporteur observed that the conditions of prisons and detention centres
visited varied from adequate to unsatisfactory. Some areas of concern were unhygienic
conditions, including insufficient sanitation, the presence of bedbugs and other pests, poor
ventilation and lighting, and overcrowding. The Special Rapporteur heard complaints about
the irregular provision of adequate food and water, a lack of privacy and insufficient family
visits.
43. Medical centres existed; however, it seemed they were not always accessible to
detainees upon request, due to a shortage of doctors. While doctors were on duty in two
prisons visited, the Special Rapporteur heard allegations that detainees sometimes had to
wait weeks for an appointment. In the establishments visited, the Special Rapporteur
detected dreadful oral hygiene, with multiple and significant dental problems requiring
urgent treatment. The accompanying forensic expert did not detect situations of detainees
with infectious contagious diseases, such as tuberculosis.
44. The Kasserine prison was composed of a large compound with several large
dormitory cells that have natural light and a fresh air supply through an iron grid. One of
the cellblocks was overcrowded, housing about 70 detainees in three rows of beds, with
very little space to move between the rows, although it seemed well maintained. The
Special Rapporteur notes that the prison provides no separation of convicted and pretrial
detainees. The prison allegedly held no minors at the time of the visit. The cells included a
shower, toilet and sink. In most cases, toilets in cells were open and did not allow for
privacy. According to the prison director, the Kasserine civilian prison accommodated 277
prisoners; of these, nine were women, 176 had been convicted and the rest were awaiting
trial.
45. The Bourj al-Roumi prison in Bizerte, the oldest prison in Tunisia, was divided into
two wings: one old and one new, each housing 450 detainees. During the revolution,
detainees took control of the detention facility for several weeks; as a result, the main part
of the prison was destroyed. Medical facilities were also affected. Of 32 cells, only 7 were
operational at the time of the visit. The cells included a shower, an open toilet and a sink in
a deplorable hygienic state. The poor kitchen conditions clearly affect hygiene. The cells
6
10
Number in penal institutions, including pretrial detainees. International Centre for Prison Studies,
World Prison Brief: Tunisia, available from
www.prisonstudies.org/info/worldbrief/wpb_country.php?country=50. The brief cites figures
provided by the Ministry of Justice of Tunisia, as at January 2011.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents