B. Proceedings after the author's return to France in 1995
4.4
Contrary to what is asserted in the communication before the Committee, the author did have the
possibility, from the moment of his secret return to France in 1995, of explaining to the French administrative
authorities the risks he ran in his country of origin and securing an administrative ruling protecting him from
any action to expel him to the former Zaire. Indeed, he could validly have submitted a fresh application for
refugee status to OFPRA.
4.5
It is true that the decree dated 14 March 1997, amending the decree of 2 May 1953, stipulates that a
fresh application for recognition of refugee status must be preceded by a fresh application for provisional
authorization to reside in France. It is nonetheless the case that the decree was adopted only in March 1997,
and cannot therefore be invoked by the author as a reason for not applying to OFPRA between March 1995,
when he returned to France, and March 1997, when the new decree was published.
4.6
Moreover, the obligation, deriving from article 2 of the Act of 25 July 1952 establishing OFPRA, to
make oneself known to the authorities at the prefecture before applying to OFPRA for recognition of refugee
status does not render registration of such a request by OFPRA contingent upon a prior decision by the
prefecture to give permission to reside in France.
4.7
Even if an alien is not granted authorization to reside legally in France with a duly issued permit, he
is always entitled to have his application for refugee status considered by OFPRA. Article 2 of the
aforementioned Act of 25 July 1952 states that, when provisional authorization to reside in France is withheld,
OFPRA shall accord priority to examination of the request for recognition of refugee status, and article 12 of
the same Act says that an alien to whom permission to reside in France has not been granted on any of the
grounds set forth in article 10 shall nonetheless be entitled to remain in France until the decision reached by
OFPRA is notified.
4.8
Thus, though indeed not entitled to obtain a residence permit as long as the ban on his presence on
French territory remained in effect, the author cannot seriously assert that this prevented him from submitting
a fresh application for refugee status or emphasizing the risks he would run if returned to his home country.
Furthermore, since his banishment from French territory ceased to be effective as from March 1997, the author
could thereafter have submitted an application for recognition of refugee status subject to the usual conditions.
4.9
Given that the author could prove that he had been returned to his country of origin after the rejection
of his application by OFPRA and CRR in 1993, a fresh application for recognition of refugee status would have
been regarded as a first application and not as an "abuse of process" or "deliberate fraud", which could, under
the terms of article 10 of the Act of 25 July 1952, justify a refusal of provisional authorization to reside in
France. The author could thus have been granted a provisional authorization to reside in France until OFPRA
and, on appeal, CRR had ruled on his application.
4.10 Nor can the author maintain that the judicial authorities could not have been persuaded to lift the order
banning him from France after his secret return in 1995. Article 28 bis of the ordinance of 2 November 1945
does indeed say that an application to lift a ban from French territory can be entertained only if the alien is
living outside France, but the same article provides for an exception where the alien is subjected to a restricted
residence order. Since such an order is issued by the administrative authorities when it is established that the
individual concerned cannot return to his country of origin because, inter alia, of the risks he might be exposed
to there, the author was at liberty to appear before the authorities in the appropriate prefecture to have his
situation considered in that regard. He refrained from taking such a step.
169
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents