E/CN.4/1998/38
page 37
unrestrained brutality by the law enforcement officials involved, as well as
at the allegations of judicial complicity in and aggravation of the cruelty of
the events. He also believes that the incident must be regarded as a
calculated defiance of the United Nations and its continuing concern to
promote respect for human rights in the Sudan.
Swaziland
181. The Special Rapporteur made one urgent appeal on behalf of one
individual, to which the Government replied.
Sweden
182. The Special Rapporteur made one urgent appeal on behalf of one asylum
seeker.
Switzerland
183. The Special Rapporteur, in conjunction with the Special Rapporteur on
the independence of judges and lawyers, transmitted allegations concerning
one person, to which the Government responded on two occasions. The
Government also sent replies to two cases transmitted in 1996, concerning
three individuals.
Observations
184. The Special Rapporteur appreciates the detailed responses of the
Government. The facts in the Nwankavo case, where there was overwhelming
evidence of abuse leading finally to some welcome disciplinary action against
the law enforcement officials involved, suggest a judicial disposition
precipitately and prematurely to believe the police and to disbelieve the
foreign accused/complainant, as well as a reluctance fully to rectify the
original wrong. He notes the concern of the Human Rights Committee “at the
numerous allegations of ill-treatment in the course of arrests or police
custody, particularly in respect of foreign nationals or Swiss citizens of
foreign origin and ... reports on the failure of the authorities to follow up
complaints of ill-treatment by the police and the disproportionate nature, if
not absence, of penalties” (A/52/40, para. 98). The Committee against Torture
has expressed similar concerns (see CAT/C/308).
Syrian Arab Republic
185. The Special Rapporteur transmitted two urgent appeals on behalf of
two individuals. The Government replied to one of the appeals.
Tunisia
186. The Special Rapporteur transmitted to the Government an urgent appeal on
behalf of two people, and received a reply from the Government. He also had
replies from the Government concerning two cases submitted in 1996.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents