Recommendation
(A/HRC/4/33/Add.3)
(g) The power to order
or approve arrest and
supervision of the
police and detention
facilities of the
prosecutors be
transferred to
Steps taken in previous years
(to be found in A/HRC/7/3/Add.2)
General Prosecutor to monitor the
situation in prisons; the latter created
a registry for complaints in the
Attorney-General’s Office
Information received on steps taken since
December 2007/current situation
inside Swaqa prison to receive complaints
from prisoners on a weekly basis.
However, the NCHR was not allowed
access to Swaqa prison during
disturbances which occurred in the prison
in April 2008. The Ministry of Interior’s
Public Security Directorate was then
reported to stop its cooperation with the
NCHR following its critical reporting of
the April 2008 events
• However, partly due to the fear of
retaliation and the lack of a clear strategy
of Grievance and Human Rights officials
for the protection of witnesses and
complainants, these complaint
mechanisms still fall short of protecting
prisoners from torture and other illtreatment
Non-governmental sources: the discussion
regarding separation of the two authorities
is ongoing.
A/HRC/10/44/Add.5
page 53
(f) The right to legal
counsel be legally
guaranteed from the
moment of arrest
Situation during visit
(A/HRC/4/33/Add.3)
refer the person to a
forensic doctor
• Within the Public Security
Directorate a Complaints
and Human Rights Office
received complaints
against its personnel
• A human rights
directorate within the
Ministry of Interior was
mandated to follow up on
general human rights
issues and complaints
• The NCHR was tasked
with addressing human
rights issues through a
monitoring mechanism
and the examination of
complaints related to
government institutions
CCP provided that, in the
period following the arrest and
before being presented to the
Public Prosecutor, legal
counsel could not be sought.
Security services were
effectively shielded from
independent criminal
prosecution and judicial
scrutiny as abuses by officials
of those services were dealt
with by a special court system,
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents