E/CN.4/1995/34
page 80
Hospital to Ramallah prison hospital and a relative visiting him six days
later observed that his head was swollen from injury and that he was having
difficulty walking, sleeping and retaining food and water. He was allegedly
denied medical treatment at Ramallah prison hospital so as to coerce him into
making a confession.
418. Sami Ismail Issa Fawaghreh, from Al-Khader village near Bethlehem on
the West Bank, sustained severe head injuries in an automobile accident and a
metal plate was put in his skull. In December 1990, at the time he was due
to undergo another operation, he was arrested and during interrogation was
allegedly struck on the head with a metal bar, rupturing the plate and causing
him to go into a coma for three days. He was said subsequently to suffer from
recurrent epileptic seizures. His condition was said to be continually
deteriorating and his life to be at great risk without surgery to remove the
broken plate, which was allegedly being denied to him by prison authorities.
419. Makdam Makdad was sentenced to eight years’ imprisonment in 1987 and had
been kept in solitary confinement, despite being diagnosed as a schizophrenic.
Prison authorities were said to have justified the treatment on the grounds
that he had refused hospitalization in a mental health centre. The Gaza
prison was said to lack facilities for psychiatric hospitalization and
prolonged detention in solitary confinement was said to be likely to lead to a
further deterioration in his mental health.
420. The Special Rapporteur also transmitted information alleging that prior
to the commencement of interrogation of a detainee by the secret service or
military, a physician might be called upon to examine the detainee in order to
determine whether he or she was physically fit to undergo such interrogation
procedures as blindfolding and prolonged standing. It was alleged that the
assessment of the physician was made in the form of responses to a
questionnaire which the physician was requested to complete after examining
the detainee. The Israeli Medical Association, responsible for regulating
Israeli medical practices, has reportedly forbidden physicians to answer the
questionnaires on the grounds that they contravened international norms and
rules of medical ethics.
Urgent appeals and replies received
421. The Special Rapporteur transmitted an urgent appeal on 21 March 1994
concerning Sha’wan Rateb Jabarin, a member of the human rights organization
Al-Haq, who was arrested on 10 March 1994 at his home in Sa’ir Hebron
district. He had reportedly been arrested on previous occasions and had
served a total of 19 months of administrative detention since 1987, when he
had allegedly been subjected to serious ill-treatment. He was said to suffer
from a heart condition which necessitated regular medication.
422. The Special Rapporteur transmitted another urgent appeal
on 15 August 1994 concerning Hani Saleh ’Abdullah Muzher, who was arrested
on 13 July 1994 and taken to Ramallah prison for interrogation. He was denied
access to a lawyer until 11 August, when he told his lawyer that he had been
kept shackled in a painful position for prolonged periods, deprived of sleep
for at least a week, and had received threats against his life and well-being.
He had also slit his wrist on 20 July so that he could be treated to get a
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents