E/CN.4/1995/34
page 81
break from interrogation. A doctor reportedly recommended that he should not
be left alone in his cell and should be allowed to rest for one night. A
statement from the State Attorney’s Office was said to have indicated that
Hani Muzher was sleeping like other detainees, but suggested that the
situation might change depending on developments in the interrogation. In
view of this statement and allegations of ill-treatment already undergone,
fears were expressed that he might be subjected to further torture or
ill-treatment.
423. On 18 October 1994 the Government replied that Hani Saleh Abdullah
Muzher, who was in Ramallah prison for questioning, had been prevented from
having an unsupervised meeting with his attorney during the preliminary stage
of his interrogation for security reasons. By an agreement reached between
his attorney and the security services, it was decided that he could meet his
attorney freely and without restrictions from 11 August. He had tried both
on 14 and 30 July to injure himself by cutting his left wrist. He had
received appropriate medical care, was checked daily by an orderly and, if
necessary, by a doctor. His interrogators were instructed to take appropriate
measures to prevent a recurrence of the attempts at self-injury. It was also
agreed between the security services and his attorney that he was not to be
deprived of sleep.
424. On 17 November 1994 the Special Rapporteur transmitted an urgent appeal
on behalf of Ahmad Ibrahim Sa’id, who was reportedly arrested on 29 June 1994
and subsequently charged with activities on behalf of Hamas. Some time after
his arrest he was allegedly hooded, beaten, shackled in painful positions for
prolonged periods, and deprived of sleep. His interrogation was said to have
resumed in Ashkelon prison on 20 September 1994, during which he was allegedly
hooded, forced to stand for 18 to 20 hours per day and forced to sit on a
chair in an uncomfortable position with his hands tied while interrogators
pushed him in an attempt to make him fall. He was also said to have been
threatened that he would be paralysed and unable to have children following
his interrogation.
Observations
425. The Special Rapporteur notes that, consistent with his observations of
last year (E/CN.4/1995/31, para. 358), the Committee against Torture at its
twelfth session, following its consideration of Israel’s initial report,
expressed great concern "at the large number of heavily documented cases of
ill-treatment in custody". (A/49/44, para. 169)
Italy
Information transmitted to the Government and replies received
426. By letter dated 19 August 1994 the Special Rapporteur transmitted to the
Government three cases of torture that allegedly occurred in the country and
on 14 November 1994 the Government sent replies to those allegations. The
allegations and the replies are summarized in the following paragraphs.
427. Arsenie Reutu, a Romanian national arrested in Milan on 27 May 1993,
reportedly told the court at a preliminary investigation on 29 May that the
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents