PRISON MANAGEMENT
poorly defined and there is limited
empirical evidence to show that
interventions with prisoners actually
drive positive attitudinal change with
any consistency.
The concept of disengagement
refers directly to behavioural change,
and it is most often defined in
terms of individuals denouncing
their commitment to violence.
Disengagement-related interventions
may include counselling, faith-based
dialogue, education, vocational
training, sport and exercise, and
increased contact with family. To be
effective, interventions need to be
sensitive to the different experiences
of women and girls. Again, evidence
of the impact of interventions to
encourage disengagement from
violence is limited.
Another ongoing dilemma is whether
to keep prisoners who have been
assessed as having violent extremist
views separate from the ordinary
prison population – or whether to
disperse them among other prisoners.
Conclusive evidence of the benefits
of either approach is not available,
but in general there is a reluctance to
36 |
accept the risk of integrating prisoners
convicted of terrorist offences, as well
as pressure from the public for a visible
response of segregation. Research
conducted in the Philippines over a
10-year period compared the situation
of prisoners convicted of terrorist
offences who had been dispersed in
the general population with those who
were isolated.388 It found that isolation
can lead to a negative entrenchment
of attitudes, while dispersal can lead
to a positive change in attitudes
over time.389
The rehabilitation and reintegration of
prisoners who hold violent extremist
views demands a multi-agency
approach in order to be truly
effective, involving prison staff but
also including probation, social
welfare, housing and education
authorities. This kind of inter-agency
working creates challenges in terms
of sharing confidential information
and competition over resources
and funding, but it is essential for
the reintegration of this group of
prisoners.390 A review of prisons in
New South Wales, Australia, found
little evidence of radicalisation to
violence amongst prisoners but
made recommendations for action,
including the establishment of
a dedicated unit to lead and advise
on managing violent extremists, which
will assist multi-agency working. It also
recommended increasing intelligence
capacity and capability, and enhancing
services to Muslim prisoners to reduce
vulnerability to radicalisation.391
RECOMMENDATION 19
Strategies to prevent and
manage violent extremism
in prisons should be
proportionate and founded upon
international standards and the
implementation of the Nelson
Mandela Rules. Prison staff
should be trained to respond
appropriately and rehabilitation
programmes should adopt
a multi-agency approach.
Penal Reform International and Thailand Institute of Justice | Global Prison Trends 2019
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents