79
rights the law provides the accused, which basically amount to the
possibility of seeking and providing evidence, disputing evidence
connected with the case, and challenging decisions that are made.
These elements of a defense, along with any others provided under
domestic law, should be used properly by the defense, which should
act diligently and effectively in the proceedings in order to ensure not
only that the rights of the accused are respected, but also that the
decisions handed down in the case are in line with the law and with
283, 284
justice.
194.
Regarding the imposition of pretrial detention, as will be seen below,
the simple fact that a person facing a criminal trial is under the custody of the State and
is not at liberty, places him at a procedural disadvantage. The problems faced by the
accused in organizing his defense increase when pretrial detention is prolonged
excessively.
195.
During the preliminary stages leading up to the possible imposition of
pretrial detention, it is vital for the defense team to have timely access to all the
relevant documents on which the decision is to be based. In addition, as already noted,
it is essential that resolutions ordering or extending pretrial detention be duly
grounded, so that the defense team can clearly and precisely assess the reasons and
appraisals on which those decisions are based.
196.
Regarding the quality of defenders’ work, it is essential that their
arguments comply with the principles and criteria governing the ordering of pretrial
detention that apply in the specific case. Thus, as with judges, they may not merely
invoke provisions or pre-established legal formulas mechanically. Instead, they must be
able to provide specific information and arguments to offer the judge reliable reasons
for preserving the accused’s liberty. They would also have to provide specific arguments
regarding the factual conditions making inapplicable those precautionary measures that
are not necessary or proportional in the given case, as well as arguments regarding the
legal duration of pretrial detention in those cases in which it is admissible.
6.
Judicial oversight and resources
197.
One fundamental principle established in the Inter-American system is
that for a remedy to be effective, “it must be truly effective in establishing whether
283
IACHR, Press Release 76/11 – IACHR Recommends Adoption of a Comprehensive Public Policy on
Prisons
in
Uruguay,
Washington,
D.C.,
July
25,
2011,
Annex,
available
at
http://www.oas.org/en/iachr/media_center/PReleases/2011/076A.asp, para. 53.
284
In this regard, the United Nations Basic Principles on the Role of Lawyers are relevant,
particularly Principle 14, which provides as follows: “Lawyers, in protecting the rights of their clients and in
promoting the cause of justice, shall seek to uphold human rights and fundamental freedoms recognized by
national and international law and shall at all times act freely and diligently in accordance with the law and
recognized standards and ethics of the legal profession.”
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents