CAT/OP/GBR/CSPRO/1
prisoners. Prisons are challenging places to live and work. Staff and prisoners are
increasingly exposed to threats including levels of violence, the impacts of substance misuse
and criminal activity, all of which increase the risk for potential physical harm. Reducing
violence and improving staff prisoner relationships will reduce the need for force to be used.
66.
We are working with the Race Action Plan team to tackle disproportionality. We have
accepted the Lammy recommendation that Use of Force committees should not be ethnically
homogenous and involve at least one individual with explicit remit to consider interests of
prisoners. We are working towards implementing this across all our prisons.
67.
A Use of Force evaluation team has been established to conduct research into use of
force in prisons, and we will use this evidence to inform our approach moving forward, so
that we can use evidence-based practice to tackle disproportionality.
Scotland
68.
In 2021, Police Scotland will engage in a consultation with community stakeholders
in order to inform revised Use of Force Policy. As part of the consultation views will be
sought from ethnic minority stakeholders on policies that ensure proportionate use of force.
69.
Operational Safety Training Instructors will also undertake for the first time,
additional, externally provided Equality and Diversity training in order to better inform
training development and operational safety course content. The training will deepen their
understanding of equality and diversity related issues in their role in the provision of advice
on the proportionate use of force.
Police Scotland intend to utilise this enhanced knowledge to provide specific tactical advice
to officers to counteract the effect of any biases they may hold.
“c) implement programmes, which support reintegration, produce tangible outcomes
and focus on preventing reoffending of persons from ethnic minority background in
prisons,”
70.
Across the range of interventions and programmes that address reducing reoffending,
we will need to ensure that we understand the impact across cohorts and consider how we
address specific needs in all that we do. This can be observed in our evaluation programme
and our work analysing the drivers of reoffending for cohorts. We aim to carry out equality
impact assessments in our programmes and work to ensure that factors such as protected
characteristics, do not act as a hinderance for successful rehabilitation.
71.
Following the HMIP ‘Thematic review of Minority ethnic prisoners’ experiences of
rehabilitation and release planning’ an action plan has been agreed to enable Her Majesty’s
Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) to make the changes identified to improve matters
for the identified cohort. Fundamentally, the purpose of this work is to understand the cultural
needs of Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic (BAME) and Gypsy, Roma and Travellers (GRT)
prisoners in order to provide improved and culturally sensitive services around rehabilitation
and release planning. This will include working to identify potential areas of discrimination
and embedding improvements into the services HMPPS offers so that minority ethnic
prisoners’ experiences are improved, aiding their rehabilitation.
“d) reduce the over-representation of children from ethnic minorities in youth custody,
including through adoption of alternatives to detention;”
72.
We want people to have confidence in a justice system
where no person suffers discrimination of any sort. We share
where we are now in terms of disproportionality. We will
understanding and tackling of disproportionality within the
recognise the absolute need for systemic change.
that is fair and open - one
deeply the concerns about
continue to prioritise the
youth justice system and
73.
While there is important work to be done to improve the treatment and outcomes of
these communities in the Criminal Justice System, this will only partially address the key
issues linked to over-representation. This is because the ‘upstream’ factors that lead to crime
are similarly disproportional. That is why there have been wider efforts by the Government
to tackle over-representation through health, education and policing - demonstrating the
significance of a holistic approach.
13