1.6 Visit to the Idrija psychiatric hospital
It is recommended that the form for the patient’s consent on admission to the close surveillance unit
includes also the date and time of the signature as they are not necessary the same as the date and
time of the admission.
We welcome that the hospital’s response report stated that the consent form on the admission to
intensive care unit will be updated according to the Ombudsman’s recommendations.
It is recommended that the hospital’s gerontopsychiatric unit immediately prepares a room where
special protection measures could be properly performed or (always) applies this measure in a room
used for special protection measure in other units (in unit L3, for example).
We welcome that the hospital’s response report stated that suitable premisses for special protection
measures will be ensured in the gerontopsychiatric unit in the same way as in other units.
It is recommended that strapping to chairs as a form of special protection measure is performed only in
appropriate rooms (onto the bed or chair) under full control of the personnel.
The hospital’s response report stated that intensive care ward of the gerontopsychiatric unit accepts patients
with delirious conditions or suffering from a progressed form of dementia with mental and behavioural
disorders. Worsening of the condition and the need for hospitalisation in the gerontopsychiatric unit often
happen concurrently with infectious diseases or conditions after injuries or surgical procedures. Patients
with dementia in the gerontopsychiatric unit need appropriate somatic and psychiatric diagnosis and
treatment; the accompanying measures ensure optimal conditions for persons who need continuous
assistance and care during all activities due to their actual condition. Specific problems of patients suffering
from dementia include balance problems and reduced motor skills which result in an increased risk of falls
or inability to walk. Since these patients do not fully comprehend their medical condition and have a severe
decline in cognitive abilities, they are usually uncritical to their condition and exposed to frequent falls and
injuries. The injuries of the skeleton and brain haemorrhage significantly increase the mortality rate of
patients with dementia. Given the basic characteristics of the medical condition of patients with dementia
which can result in invalidity, the nature of measures and assistance is different than with patients who are
not suffering from dementia. Patients need assistance with all activities (hygiene, feeding, movement); to
avoid the risk of falls, special safety measures are taken and wheelchairs or resting chairs are used. With
this measure the hospital ensures the patients’ safety and that they live in a favourable social environment
while staying in the hospital as a part of a therapeutic group or in communal living areas. Despite the severe
decline in cognitive abilities, speech impairments and disturbances in perception, cohabitation with other
patients and the therapeutic staff is an important prerequisite for achieving appropriate communication
skills, emotional response as well as appropriate and suitable supervision. Separating patients with
advanced dementia who need increased supervision due to falls and injuries would mean additional social
isolation and absence of normal stimuli and communication, made possible when staying in a therapeutic
group or communal living areas.
The NPM’s report pointed out the difference between protection measures and special protection measures
which is also confirmed by the NPM medical expert opinion. The NPM agrees that it is not appropriate to
separate patients under protection measures that go on during almost the whole time that the patient
spends in the living area. However, the situation changes if there is a special protection measure (in its
response, the hospital perhaps erroneously uses this expression when defining protection measures in the
gerontopsychiatric unit). We repeat that it is necessary to respect all requirements determined by the ZDZdr
when strapping the patient onto the bed or chair is used to prevent or control their dangerous behaviour
and when patients pose a threat to their or somebody else’s life or health or when such behaviour causes
severe material damage to the patient or others and this danger cannot be prevented with other less
severe measures. Since the measure as determined by ZDZdr has a strict time limit, the separation of the
patient for the duration of the measure might not have such severe consequences as those which could
have resulted from exposing the patient to other patients during the special protection measure.
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE DUTIES AND POWERS OF THE NPM IN 2013
NATIONAL PREVENTIVE MECHANISM UNDER THE OPTIONAL PROTOCOL TO THE UN CONVENTION AGAINST TORTURE AND OTHER CRUEL, INHUMAN OR DEGRADING TREATMENT OR PUNISHMENT
127
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents