solitary confinement, as well as with several other inmates and the prisoners’ coresponsibility body. It inspected the files of several inmates who were accommodated in solitary confinement. The capacity of the prison was 553 places on the
visiting day. It was occupied with 487 inmates in the closed section.
Positive findings
The Commission took note of the gratifyingly low number of fixations (2010
none, 2011 one, 2012 one so far). It is exemplary that fixation with a belt system
takes place on a hospital bed which is located in the prison infirmary. This guarantees that the fixed persons can be provided with medical care. The Joint Commission gained the impression that the atmosphere between the inmates and the
officers was relaxed and friendly, which also became clear in talks both with the
inmates and with staff. In this context, the Commission welcomed the fact that all
the officers in the prison wear name badges. The Commission was also pleased
that solitary confinement is not implemented in a separate area of the prison, but
that inmates are able to remain in their cells in the respective wing.
Recommendations of the Joint Commission and the reaction of the RhinelandPalatinate Ministry of Justice and for Consumer Protection
Because of the panoptic construction, out-of-cell time is only implemented in a
more modern department which has separate floors. Out-of-cell time is also to be
introduced in the other departments, as is also possible in other similar detention
facilities.
Reaction: The recommendation had been examined. Out-of-cell time was however
not viable in the departments of the prison mentioned since they had open floors
which were not separated. General out-of-cell time would entail considerable risks
to security and order. It was furthermore not possible to maintain an overview of
where each inmate was in departments with up to 130 inmates. The RhinelandPalatinate Ministry of Justice stated by letter dated 17 December 2012 that implementation was refused.
In accordance with section 143 subsection (2) of the Prison Act, the penal institutions are to be organised in such a manner that inmates can be formed into
groups which can be kept under supervision for care and treatment in order to
offer inmates a social learning environment. Several hours’ locking up of inmates
together per day cannot replace detention in accommodation groups. Locking up
inmates together is a measure in which inmates are left to their own devices
without supervision, and is hence problematic as a resocialisation measure. The
Joint Commission hence recommended to set the stage for detention in accommodation groups.
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents