PREFACE
The National Agency for the Prevention of Torture
is the body responsible in Germany for ensuring
humane detention conditions and treatment of
prisoners. The Agency hereby presents an annual
report of its activities to the Federal Government, the
German Bundestag, the Länder governments and the
Länder parliaments. The Report covers the period
from 1 January to 31 December 2017.
This activity report will first provide an
introduction to the National Agency's mandate and
its working methods. The next chapter describes the
standards the National Agency has developed – in
addition to its visits – as benchmarks for humane
detention and treatment conditions in the institutions
visited. These standards are derived from the Agency's
recurring recommendations and are continually
developed and adapted. They can also be found on the
National Agency's website.
This is followed by a report on the Agency's focus of
activity in 2017: the deprivation of liberty by the
police. In the context of this, the Agency not only
visited police stations of all Länder, but also observed
police measures carried out at major events.
One issue that continues to arise regularly with
regard to police custody is the use of physical
restraints. Such use of physical restraints is permitted
in some of the Länder, and in some facilities this
measure is even applied regularly. The National
Agency is critical of this, since the use of physical
restraint constitutes a severe interference with rights
to freedom, and involves considerable risks for the
person under restraint. In most cases, police stations
do not have suitable restraint systems, nor are persons
being restrained supervised without interruption by a
qualified person (so-called “Sitzwache”).
This focus topic is followed by a report on the
National Agency's visits in all of its other areas of
competence.
Significant deficiencies were found in the Karlsruhe,
Traunstein, Stuttgart and Berlin Tegel prisons. Here,
the National Agency repeatedly encountered
detention conditions that infringe human dignity and
must be rectified.
The National Agency increased the number of its
visits, especially those to care facilities and social
institutions, and also conducted a number of followup visits in order to check on the implementation of
its
recommendations.
The
findings
and
recommendations made by the National Agency in
the course of its visits are summarised in this Annual
Report.
The National Agency only publishes the names of
the institutions it visited if these are state-funded.
This applies to the publication of both the visit
reports and the respective statements made by the
competent ministries. The reason for this is that there
are considerable doubts as to whether the legal basis
for the National Agency's work (the Optional
Protocol to the Convention against Torture and
Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or
Punishment in conjunction with the ratifying
legislation of 26 August 2008) is specific enough to
justify the publication of information pertaining to
privately run institutions, particularly in view of their
rights under Article 14 of the German Basic Law
[Grundgesetz, GG].
This impairs the National Agency's preventive work
and reduces its effectiveness.
The National Agency therefore considers it
necessary that a sufficient legal basis be established,
allowing the National Agency to publish the names of
all the institutions it visited as well as visit reports and
statements, which would enable it to fulfil its mandate
in terms of prevention as provided for in the Optional
Protocol.
6