E/CN.4/2001/66/Add.2
page 109
Alex Sandro Santos da Nóbrega, Antônio Gomes Ferreira de Araújo, Elias Fernandes
dos Santos, Edilson Santos Barbalho and Luiz Ferreira da Silva, detained at the Silvio Porto
Penal Prison in João Pessoa, were reportedly beaten by 30 to 40 police officers on 12 July 2000.
The officers, some of whom were allegedly masked, reportedly used wooden sticks, baseball
bats, clubs and guns to beat them and allegedly shot into the air several times. Prisoners were
also allegedly verbally abused. It is believed that an attempted break-out occurred on
7 July 2000 and the police officers were searching for the tools used. A judge reportedly visited
the prison and photographed the detainees’ bodies and tape recorded their reports about the
incident. According to the information received, there are witnesses to the case. The detainees
are said to have constantly been threatened by the prison guards not to comment about the
incident. An inquiry was allegedly opened on 14 July 2000 and three prisoners with less
severe beating marks than the others reportedly underwent an official medical examination
on 15 July 2000.
State of Paraná
186. Valdir José Chamoskovisk, a detainee at the Central Prison of Piraquara, also known as
“General”, has reportedly been kept for seven years in an isolation cell and has only very
recently been allowed to be visited by a doctor. He is reported to be suffering from mental
illness. He was reportedly sentenced to 18 years’ imprisonment.
187. Valdecir Bordignon, Lorival Lesse and Aristide dos Santos Lisboa, agricultural
workers, were among a group of 30 families that reportedly occupied a farm in Paraná on
26 April 1999. On 29 April, two court officials, some 10 officers from the civil police Special
Operation Group wearing black vests and masks, two plain clothes civil police officers and
20 military police officers arrived at the farm with a court order requiring the families to leave.
The workers reportedly intended to leave the area right away, but the police officers allegedly
barred them from doing so and forced them to sit in the sun for five hours. They are also said to
have verbally abused the workers, to have threatened to beat them and to rape the women. Four
police officers reportedly took Valdecir Bordignon away and handcuffed, kicked and punched
him. He was allegedly beaten with clubs and his head submerged in the cattle’s drinking pool.
Officers are said to have interrogated him about the leadership of the landless movement
(movimento dos sem terra, MST). He allegedly answered that he did not know. He was then
reportedly dunked eight times, finally losing consciousness. He was allegedly pushed onto the
ground and then woken up. Officers reportedly stepped on his neck, and threatened to “impale”
him with a stalk of sugar cane. He was then allegedly forced to kneel and, with a knife and a gun
held to his neck, forced to eat half a kilo of cattle manure. According to the information
received, after two and a half hours of torture, he was reportedly forced to sign the court order.
According to the information received, he was taken with other farm workers to the Ortigueira
police station where they allegedly reported the incident to a judge. The latter reportedly
registered the case as an arrest in flagrante delicto and ordered them detained. They allegedly
underwent an official medical examination on the same day. It is reported that the medical
report registered lesions consistent with the allegations. They were reportedly taken back to the
police station, where they reportedly remained for four days. They were later transferred to the
Ponta Grossa jail, where they allegedly remained for about 38 days. Military police officers are
said to have constantly threatened to rape their wives and to kill them when the prison guards
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents