272. Medical care at Guantánamo appears to have improved over time. Interlocutors informed
ODIHR that for certain medical conditions, the present quality of care seems to be
equivalent or higher than in other detention facilities in the United States. However,
aspects of basic medical care at Guantánamo are said to remain problematic and
inadequate.583
273. Whereas some former detainees reportedly said they received appropriate medical care at
Guantánamo,584 a number of reports and concurring testimonies appear to contradict this
conclusion. Medical care, especially prior to 2008, has been said to not only be “inadequate
and negligent, but also abusive”.585
274. In interviews with ODIHR, former detainees transferred from Guantánamo between 2006
and 2009 relayed complaints of long delays or denial of medical treatment, inadequate
care, and provision of treatment conditioned upon co-operation with interrogators, as well
as humiliating treatment by medical personnel and forced drugging during their detention.
More specifically, they indicated that their medical and dental treatment had been denied
or delayed for a year or more.586 In addition, they described that when they did receive
medical care, the treatment was provided in humiliating circumstances and was often
inadequate. Mustafa Ait Idir explained that after half of his face was paralysed following a
beating, a medical technician “started making fun of [him], humiliating [him, asking if he
had] AIDS (…) The technician said he would give [him] a sleeping pill (…) [He] gave
[him] a small plaster and told [him] to put it over [his] eye when [he] wanted to sleep and
to take it off when [he] was not sleeping”.587 He and Lakhdar Boumediene also recalled
circumstances where medical staff told them that they needed to co-operate with
interrogators to receive their medication. Some of the former detainees interviewed by
ODIHR also alleged being subjected to forced drugging and receiving medication for
mental-illness without their consent.588
583
ODIHR interview with Brigadier General Stephen Xenakis, op. cit., note 231; ODIHR interview with Scott Allen, op. cit.,
note 231; ODIHR interview with the Center for Constitutional Rights, op. cit., note 255.
584
These detainees were treated for tuberculosis and a diabetic foot ulcer. Broken Laws, Broken Lives: Medical Evidence of
Torture by US Personnel and Its Impact (Cambridge: Physicians for Human Rights, 2008), p. 7,
<https://s3.amazonaws.com/PHR_Reports/BrokenLaws_14.pdf>.
585
IACHR, Ameziane v. United States, “Petition”, op. cit., note 527, para. 61.
586
ODIHR interview with David Hicks, op. cit., note 228: Hicks explained that he developed large and painful lumps in his
breasts that remained for over a year. Despite his complaints, this was not treated. He also mentioned the bad condition of his
teeth as a major problem caused by five and a half years of detention where he was not able to brush them; ODIHR interview
with Murat Kurnaz, op. cit., note 400: Kurnaz stressed that he had a severe toothache and asked, unsuccessfully, to see a dentist
for approximately two years; ODIHR interview with Lakhdar Boumediene, op. cit., note 216: Boumediene told ODIHR that he
waited for about eight months for the removal of a tooth; ODIHR interview with Mustafa Ait Idir and Hajj Boudella, op. cit., note
217: Boudella mentioned the bad condition of his teeth, which were rotten due to the water, and left untreated.
587
ODIHR interview with Mustafa Ait Idir and Hajj Boudella, ibid. Murat Kurnaz and David Hicks also described incidents
which would testify to the degrading and humiliating circumstances in which medical care was sometimes reportedly provided.
ODIHR interview with Murat Kurnaz, ibid.; ODIHR interview with David Hicks, ibid. See, also, IACHR, Ameziane v. United
States, “Petition”, op. cit., note 527, para. 61.
588
ODIHR interview with David Hicks, ibid.: Hicks stressed his fear of forced drug injections, which he said were regular and
left him without control over his body. He also reported being drugged prior to his notice of charge in 2007.; United States Court
of Military Commission Review, David Hicks v. United States of America, “Appellant’s Motion to Attach”, 5 November 2013,
paras. 257-259, <http://ccrjustice.org/files/Hicks_v_UnitedStates_MotiontoAttach%282013-11-05%29.pdf>; ODIHR interview
with Murat Kurnaz, ibid.: Kurnaz said that detainees were forced to take drugs against malaria, among other drugs, even though
there was no malaria in Guantánamo. Detainees were reportedly not informed of the side effects of the malaria medication, which
included hallucinations; ODIHR interview with Lakhdar Boumediene, op. cit., note 216: Boumediene stated that he was given
drugs every day. He alleged that he was once injected with penicillin after he had informed doctors that he was allergic to it, and
118
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents