CCPR/C/117/D/2559/2015
Shabaab attempted to forcibly recruit him over the telephone once in 2010, the Board found
that the author would not, for that reason, be at a real risk of persecution or abuse by AlShabaab or others if returned to Somalia. The State party notes that the author stated in
support of his case that he was contacted only that one time and that he had not previously
experienced any conflict with members of Al-Shabaab. It also notes that Al-Shabaab has
not contacted the author since 2010, nor has it contacted his uncle, with whom he lived at
the time of the alleged call from Al-Shabaab.
4.10 Moreover, the State party maintains that the attempt to recruit him in 2010 does not
mean that the author belongs to a group of persons who would be at risk of persecution if
returned to Somalia, nor does the background information available on Somalia support this
allegation. The State party refers to the report entitled “Update on security and protection
issues in Mogadishu and South-Central Somalia”, published by Landinfo and the Danish
Immigration Service in March 2014, in which it is stated that, according to an international
non-governmental organization: “Forced recruitment to al-Shabaab is only relevant in those
areas where al-Shabaab is in full control. Recruitment mostly takes place via the elders.
Some elders may support al-Shabaab while others do not.”7 In addition, it appeared from
the background information available that the city of Galkayo, which is where the author
was born and had lived, was controlled by the Government.8
4.11 As regards the general conditions in Somalia, including in the author’s home city of
Galkayo, the State party submits that they are not at present of such a nature as to lead to
the conclusion that everybody returning to that area is at a real risk of abuse, thereby
justifying the granting of asylum solely as a result of their presence in the area. The State
party also submits that the article dated 2 January 20159 provides information only about a
blast that killed one person and injured four others outside an international school in
Galkayo. The article includes no information on those responsible for the attack as alleged
by the author. Accordingly, the State party maintains that the author’s subjective fear of
returning to Somalia is not based on such objective facts, including the background
information available on forced recruitment and the general situation in the author’s home
region, as to constitute a sufficient basis for granting asylum.
4.12 The author has stated that the decision of the Refugee Appeals Board was contrary
to section 26 of the Aliens Act, as section 26 provides that the Board must consider whether
a foreigner with a close attachment to Denmark should be allowed to stay. The State party
observes in this respect that the above is not a correct construction of Danish law. Section
26 (1) of the Aliens Act provides as follows:
In deciding on expulsion, regard must be had to the question whether expulsion must
be assumed to be particularly burdensome, in particular because of (i) the alien’s ties
with the Danish society; (ii) the alien’s age, health, and other personal
circumstances; (iii) the alien’s ties with persons living in Denmark; (iv) the
consequences of the expulsion for the alien’s close relatives living in Denmark,
including in relation to … family unity; (v) the alien’s slight or non-existent ties
with his country of origin or any other country in which he may be expected to take
up residence; and (vi) the risk that, in cases other than those mentioned in section 7
(1) and (2) or section 8 (1) and (2), the alien will be ill-treated in his country of
origin or any other country in which he may be expected to take up residence.
4.13 The State party maintains that the provision in section 26 of the Aliens Act applies
to cases concerning expulsion from Denmark. The provision also applies to cases
7
8
9
Available from www.refworld.org/docid/539193314.html.
See, in particular, page 1 of the document entitled “Addendum to 2010 UNHCR eligibility guidelines
for assessing the international protection needs of asylum seekers from Somalia”, which relates
specifically to the city of Galkayo. Available from www.refworld.org/docid/4f675c5e2.html.
Available from http://allafrica.com/stories/201501030132.html.
5