STATISTICS OF PROCEEDINGS
PART II
PART III
Within constitutional review proceedings the following were scrutinised:
• conformity of Acts with the Constitution (105 proceedings, of these 92 based on
petitions by individuals and 13 on own initiative);
• conformity of regulations of local councils and rural municipality and city governments
with the Constitution and Acts (17 proceedings, of which 11 based on petitions by
individuals);
• conformity of regulations of Ministers with the Constitution and Acts (9 proceedings, of
these 6 based on petitions by individuals and 3 on own initiative);
• conformity of Government regulations with the Constitution and Acts (5 proceedings
based on a petition by an individual).
PART I
number of substantive proceedings of cases. Of these, 114 were opened on the basis of
petitions and 22 on own initiative.
The Chancellor reached the following opinions as a result of review of the constitutionality and
legality of legislation of general application133:
• opinion stating a finding of no conflict (79 cases);
• memorandum to executive authorities for initiating a Draft Act (7 cases)134;
• issue resolved by the institution during the proceedings (3 cases);
• memorandum to executive authorities for adopting a legislative act (1 case);
• proposal to bring an Act into conformity with the Constitution (1 case);
• proposal to bring a regulation into conformity with the Constitution (1 case).
PART IV
Figure 3. Distribution of constitutional review proceedings
Figure 4. Chancellor’s opinions upon review of conformity with the Constitution and Acts
In case of proceedings for review of conformity with the Constitution and Acts, the Chancellor
found conflict with the Constitution or an Act in 7.4% of the cases. In 2012, the indicator was
13%.
133 Within the cases opened in the previous years, in 2013 the Chancellor made 5 requests to the Riigikogu which
are available in Estonian on the website of the Chancellor of Justice.
134 Together with the cases opened in the previous years, in 2013 the Chancellor issued 21 memorandums which
are available in Estonian on the website of the Chancellor of Justice
73
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents