Report on the Performance of Activities of the National Preventive Mechanism for 2016
Implementation of NPM recommendations
During our follow-up visits to prisons in Zagreb, Rijeka, Varaždin and Split, Šibenik state and
county prisons and state prisons in Glina and Lepoglava, we assessed, among other things, to
what extent warnings and recommendations issued following our visits to penal institutions in
2015, had been implemented.
ACTING OF COMPETENT BODIES PURSUANT
TO RECOMMENDATIONS
ACTING OF COMPETENT BODIES
PURSUANT TO WARNINGS
implemented
18%
not
implemented
70%
under
consideration
6%
under
implementation
6%
implemented
not
31%
implemented
39%
under
implementation
27%
under
consideration
3%
Out of a total of 18 warnings, seven were addressed to COPSD and 11 to penal institutions. Just
like in previous years, recommendations that require considerable financial resources,
agreement between two or more administrations or amendments to regulations, have not
been implemented. Irrespective of this, high percentage of unimplemented warnings is
worrying, especially because those issued in cases that may result in torture, inhuman or
degrading treatment, additional violation of human rights of persons deprived of their liberty
or may cause conduct contrary to the law.
Out of a total of 112 recommendations, 34 were issued to the Ministry of Justice or COPSD
(four recommendations, along with Ministry of Justice and COPSD, were also addressed to
Croatian Health Insurance Fund and Ministry of Health), whereas 78 were issued to penal
institutions. Ministry of Justice and COPSD acted in accordance with 15% of granted
recommendations, whereas penal institution with 37%. On the other hand, Ministry of Justice
and COPSD failed to implement as much as 42% of recommendations and penal institutions
37%.
Even though as much as 58% of recommendations
have already been or are currently being
implemented, the fact that this is true of only 24% of
warnings, is worrying. In addition, in their reports,
COPSD and - although to a somewhat lesser extent penal institutions, have recently started to claim that
20
Even though as much as 58% of
recommendations have already been
or are currently being implemented,
the fact that this is true of only 24%
of warnings, is worrying.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents