A/HRC/7/3/Add.1
page 87
Para
Country
Date
Type
Mandate
Allegations transmitted
Government response
measures asking the Government to stay the
executions until it has decided the merits of the
case. The Government’s delegation before the
African Commission in May 2007 indicated that
the legal adviser in the office of the President has
advised ratification of the death sentences and
that the President might ratify at any time.
of the investigation and trial minutes, took heed of
the statements of all the witnesses of the defence
and responded to the request of the three
suspects to refer them to the Forensic Medicine
Authority. The court heard the pleadings of the
suspects’ defence throughout the 12 sessions. On
30 November 2006, the court issued by
consensus the death sentences on the three
suspects after it received the opinion of the Mufti
of Egypt who confirmed that the death penalty
concurs with Islamic Shari’a. According to the
provisions of the Egyptian law, courts should seek
the opinion of the Mufti on the issuance of death
sentences in order to confirm how far the death
penalty concurs with Islamic Shari’a. The Mufti’s
opinion in that regards is an advisory one. The
court sentenced the lapse of claim on two persons
who were dead, life imprisonment on one person,
and 5 to 10 years’ imprisonment on the other
suspects. After the judgment was issued, the
three convicts brought two grievances to the
Judgments Ratification Office in which they
repeated the same pleas that were previously
presented to the court. The Counsellor (Judge in
High Court appointed by the Supreme Judicial
Council) who examined the judgment studied the
grievances of the convicts and concluded in his
memorandum that: the judgment satisfied all the
legal elements according to Egyptian law; the
judgment took into consideration evidence upon
which the court established the validity of the
claim against the accused persons through their
statements, testimonies of witnesses, the police
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents