Doc. 11302 Report
260. Notwithstanding the presence of video cameras inside the cells, masked prison guards regularly looked
in and knocked on the door of the cell, demanding detainees to raise their hands to show that they are alive.
6.2.4. Mundane routines become unforgettable memories
261. Breakfast was delivered in the morning, followed by lunch in the early afternoon. The morning food was
typically two or three triangles of cheese with no foil, two slices of tomato, some boiled potatoes, bread and
olives. The afternoon food was typically boiled white rice with sliced luncheon meat.
262. On some special occasions, including certain religious holidays, special foods including cooked meat
with sauce, nuts and dates, fresh fruit and vegetables, or pieces of chocolate were delivered to the cells.
There was even provision for treats like unwrapped candy bars and dessert cakes.
263. Special routines developed around the delivery of food. The light bulb, which was always on, would be
briefly turned off; the food would be delivered; and then the light bulb would be turned back on again. There
was a hatch in the door of the cell for delivery of food but it was completely unpredictable whether the guards
would use the hatch, or open the doors and bring the food in.
264. Detainees had a bucket for a toilet, which was about a foot deep and ten inches in diameter.
265. At times the electricity supply went dead. The music stopped and the light went out. For a brief period
one could hear different voices shouting, some more distant than others but all incoherent.
6.2.5. Exertion of physical and psychological stress
266. There was a shackling ring in the wall of the cell, about half a metre up off the floor. Detainees’ hands
and feet were clamped in handcuffs and leg irons. Bodies were regularly forced into contorted shapes and
chained to this ring for long, painful periods.
267. Most persons in CIA custody attempted sooner or later to resist or protest their treatment and
interrogation. Yet their efforts would largely be in vain. According to one source involved in CIA interrogation:
“You know they are starting to crack when they come back at you; when they get really vocal or they try to
challenge your authority. So you hold out … you push them over the edge.”
268. The sound most commonly heard in cells was a constant, low-level hum of white noise from loudspeakers. Other recollections speak of an external humming noise, like aircraft, engines or a generator. The
constant noise was punctuated by blasts of loud Western music – rock music, rap music and thumping beats,
or distorted verses from the Koran, or irritating noises – thunder, planes taking off, cackling laughter, the
screams of women and children.
269. Detainees were subjected to relentless noise and disturbance and were deprived of the chance to
sleep.
270. The torture music was turned on, or at least made much louder, as punishment for perceived infractions
like raising one’s voice, calling out, or not waving quickly enough when guards demanded a response from
you.
271. The gradual escalation of applied physical and psychological exertion, combined in some cases with
more concentrated pressure periods for the purposes of interrogation, is said to have caused many of those
held by the CIA to develop enduring psychiatric and mental problems.
7. Secrecy and cover-up: how the United States and its European partners evade responsibility for
CIA clandestine operations
7.1. A case study of Khaled El-Masri
272. The circumstances of the abduction of German citizen Khaled El-Masri are exposed in some detail in
my first report of June 2006.216216 At that time it had not been possible to determine the exact circumstances
of Mr El-Masri’s return to Europe.
216. See Marty report, supra note 6, pp. 25-29.
53
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents