ECHR: The necessity for other inmates to assist disabled inmates in their everyday
hygiene routine, dressing and undressing must cause their anxiety and make them feel
inferior to the other inmates151.
It is unacceptable to imprison individuals suffering of serious physical disorders in
the conditions which are inappropriate given their health condition, or to leave those
individuals to be dependent on fellow inmates for showering, dressing or undressing.
This is a form of degrading treatment152.
☞ In the opinion of the NMPT, a solution that should be considered by the
Penitentiary Service to meet the needs of inmates suffering from chronic
physical disorders is to increase the number of prison hospital wards such as
the one operating in Czarne.
•
CONCLUSIONS ON THE CONDUCTED THEMATIC VISITS
In 2020, the NMPT carried out two thematic visits to assess the implementation of the
recommendations of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading
Treatment or Punishment (CPT), issued with regard to penitentiary establishments. The visits
demonstrated that the recommendations issued for the Polish side have not been implemented in key
areas.
Living space per prisoner
The minimum standard recommended by the CPT to the Council of Europe member states is 6
m² of floor area per person in a single cell and 4 m² of floor area per person in a multi-person cell (the
toilet area is not included). Also, every cell should have at least 2 m of space between the walls and 2.5
m between the floor and the ceiling153.
The CPT recommended to the Polish authorities154:
151
Judgment in the case Farbtuhs versus Latvia, of 2 December 2004, complaint no. 4672/02.
152
Judgment in the case D. G. versus Poland, of 12 February 2013, complaint no. 45705/07.
153
See: Living space per prisoner in prison establishments: CPT standards, 15 December 2015, CPT/Inf (2015)
44; 26th General Report of the CPT, CPT/Inf (2017) 5, para. 56; CPT report on visit to Poland, CPT/Inf (2018) 39,
para. 59.
154
See CPT report on the visit to Poland, CPT/Inf (2018) 39, paras. 59, 67 and 68.
66
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents