24
A practical guide to the Istanbul Protocol – for psychologists
chological responses are not known exactly,
several dimensions may be of significance in
the evaluation of the victims (Istanbul Protocol, § 280). These factors include, but are
not limited to the following:
1. GENERAL
• The perception, interpretation and meaning of torture by the victim:
“[…]The psychological consequences of
torture occur in the context of personal
attribution of meaning, personality development, and social, political and cultural
factors […]” (Istanbul Protocol, § 234).
Individuals react to extreme trauma like
torture in accordance with what it means
to them (Istanbul Protocol, § 236). The
generation of these meanings is an activity that is socially, culturally and politically framed. Besides this frame, the
unique implications that torture has for
each individual influence his/her ability
to describe and speak about it. The psychological reactions to trauma are closely linked with the psychological meaning
of the trauma to the person.
• The social context before, during and after torture (such as political and cultural
climate, values and attitudes toward
traumatic experiences):
• Social supports
• Existence of formal and/or informal support system
• Access and utilization of the social supports.
2. TORTURE HISTORY
• The circumstances and the nature of the
torture:
–– The severity of the traumatic events.
It is difficult to make a hierarchical list
of the severity of the atrocities on the
individual and it is problematic to estimate objectively the degree of severity. Additionally, the psychological impact of traumatic events on the person
depends on how the individual subjectively perceives the severity of the
event rather than the objective severity. Humiliation, threat to loved ones
or witnessing the torture of another
person may have a more profound effect on the victim than to exposure to
electric shocks or falanga. There are
contradictory reports in the literature
about the relationship between the severity of trauma and its consequences.
–– The intensity, chronicity, duration, frequency of the traumatic events
–– Nature of trauma (cumulative, repeated, prolonged, subsequent, continous...)
–– Additional traumas during torture period (such as witnessing atrocities,
death of family members or friends
during the same event.
• The developmental phase and age of the
victim
• Physical injuries, pain, symptoms related to torture-ill-treatment
• Ongoing threat to oneself and/or family
members (perceived or actual), risk of
persecution and re-arrestment.
3. PRE-TORTURE HISTORY
• Previous torture, previous detention history
• Previous exposure to different types of
trauma
• Awareness of and preparedness for torture event
• Awareness of psychological response to
torture
• Vulnerability or resilience traits
• Personal variables such as belief system,
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents