138
Resource book on the use of force and firearms in law enforcement
•
What other persons may be likely to be in the vicinity during the arrest?
•
Is there a place where the suspect can be arrested with a lower risk of harm to himself,
the law enforcement officials or others?
•
What actions can be taken to ensure third parties are not harmed?
Based on the nature of the allegations or charges, as well as the prior assessment, it may be advisable to first invite the person to voluntarily come to the police station and only consider going
out to make an arrest if the person does not cooperate. When a cooperative attitude is expected,
this will often be the preferred option as it requires fewer resources and is relatively risk-free.
India, for example, has recently introduced the system of “notice for appearance” so that arrest
can be avoided in minor offences.306
However, based on the answers to the questions above, the arresting authority must decide when and
where to conduct the arrest: at home, at work, in a public location? It is impossible to provide general
recommendations on where to carry out the arrest, or when, as this depends on the circumstances of
the particular case. This is why each case, whenever possible, should be carefully prepared.
At home there might be a lower probability of resistance, but there may be family members,
including children, for whom it may be traumatizing to see their parent(s) or family member
being arrested. Protocols should be developed for law enforcement personnel to follow when a
child will be present at the time of arrest of their parent and for informing children not present
at time of arrest.307 Conducting the arrest at work may have a negative impact on the person’s
reputation and lead to loss of employment. When conducting the arrest in a public space, there
may be a risk for innocent bystanders if the person acts in a violent manner.
Some law enforcement agencies recommend conducting the arrest in the early hours of the
morning, as most people will be fairly disoriented when suddenly woken up, thus will be less
able to resist effectively. In some countries, arrests are not allowed or require additional conditions during certain time frames. For example, in India it is prohibited to arrest a woman between
sunset and sunrise, except under specified conditions, in order to prevent abuse.308
When there is reason to believe that the person to be arrested is armed, preparing for the arrest
becomes even more important, and extra precautionary measures should be taken to prevent the
use of firearms. Indeed, in line with principle 9 of the BPUFF, firearms can only be used when
“less extreme measures are insufficient”, implying such measures must be exhausted first. Many
countries have specialized arrest teams for these situations, consisting of officers that have been
specifically trained for such purpose (see the section on SWAT teams on page 99).
If the arrestee is the main caretaker of one or more children, the rights of the child should be
taken into account during the planning process.309 Arrangements should be made for the care of
the children during the arrested person’s absence, or the arrested person should be allowed to
do so him or herself. If possible it is preferred to have another family member or someone close
to the children to care for them in their own home. If there is no suitable candidate, the situation
See Criminal Procedure Code of India, Section 41A.
United Nations Model Strategies and Practical Measures on the Elimination of Violence against Children in
the Field of Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, E/CN.15/2014/L.12/Rev.1 of 15 May 2015, para. 31.
308
This was an amendment to the Criminal Procedure Code in 2005 which inserted a new subsection in the
code as Section 46 subsection (4).
309
United Nations Model Strategies and Practical Measures on the Elimination of Violence against Children in
the Field of Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, para. 34(l).
306
307
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents