of follow-up recommendations one year
after the review took place based on information available. Here, the State is
requested to send a short report outlining
its implementation efforts on the selected
recommendations. NGOs have the opportunity to submit their own report on how the
implementation of these recommendations
is progressing. In this regard it is important
to lobby the State representatives to send
the status report on time since the Committee will not evaluate implementation until
it receives a report from the State. For the
NGO report, it is recommended not to submit this until the State report is submitted
since this offers an opportunity to comment
on the information provided by the State.
If the State report is significantly delayed
(by at least six months), it might be relevant to submit the NGO report without a
State report to comment on. In this way,
the Committee can use the NGO report as
a pressure mechanism for the State to submit its own information.
Lastly, the OHCHR has an extensive programme focused on providing technical
assistance to States. If your Government
indicates a genuine interest in implementing the Concluding Observations, it may be
useful to seek the involvement of OHCHR in
supporting their implementation. This can
be done through the Committee secretariat, through the country or regional office
or directly with the Field Operations and
Technical Cooperation Division (FOTCD) of
OHCHR.
On coalition-building and
collaboration with other NGOs
In all our work, the IRCT strongly encourages collaboration between NGOs in
coalitions or other suitable formats. In
the human rights review process, NGO
coalitions are often more visible and have
more impact than single NGO submissions,
given that Committee members have limited time and thus prefer to read reports
that are comprehensive and represent an
agreed position among NGOs.
The State reporting process can be an opportunity to build stronger cooperation
between NGOs in the area of international
advocacy, and it can be a tool for coalitionbuilding and strengthening links between
NGOs nationally.
What has to be considered for NGOs working on very specific issues is the visibility of
their own analysis and recommendations
within the coalition report. It is perfectly
legitimate to both contribute to a coalition
report and to submit a separate report on
issues of special concern to your organisation if you feel that there are certain issues
that need separate attention.
Engaging with State reviews in the UN Committee against Torture: A practical guide
23
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents