E/CN.A/1990/17
page 15
Egypt
54. On 22 September 1989 the Special Rapporteur sent an urgent appeal
to the Government of Egypt concerning information alleging that
approximately 60 persons (journalists, lawyers, trade unionists and members
of the legal political opposition) were arrested during the night of
23/24 August 1989, held in Al Salam police station until 27 August, and then
transferred to Abu Za'Abel prison. According to a number of prisoners later
released, all reportedly suffered indiscriminate beating following a hunger
strike on 28 August by 10 detainees protesting about prison conditions. The
10 protesters themselves were reportedly beaten individually and placed in
solitary confinement. The following 23 persons were reportedly still being
held by the police and fears have been expressed that they might be subjected
to torture and ill-treatment while in detention: Riyad Rifat, Muhammad Riyad,
Eamid Khalifa, Fikri Labib, Ibrahim Fathi, Ahmad Sadiq, Muhammad Abdel
Salam Al Barbari, Muhammad Zaki Al Hifnawi, Mahrous Mahmoud Surour,
Muhammad Abdel Fattah Abdel Hay, Abdel Khaliq Farouq, Gihad Taman,
'Imad 'Atiya, Abdel Aziz Ash-Shinawi, Ahmed Abdel Raziq, Sa'id Abdel
Min'Im Natour, Fatahallah Mahrous, Shafiq Sa'id Allam, Ad-DasBOuqi Sulaiman
Ad-Dassouqi, Abdel Min'Imm Al Maghrabi, 'Adil Idris, Jamal Abdel Hamid
Jamal Idris, Hamdi Sabir As-Siba'I, Ad-Dassouqi Sulaiman Al Gharib,
Muhammad Ahmed Al-Lithi, Mus'Ad Taha Sulaiman, Nabil Nour Ad-Din.
55. On 2 October 1989 the Special Rapporteur addressed a letter to the
Government of Egypt transmitting information alleging that despite legislation
which prohibited torture, invalidated confessions obtained under duress and
made the infliction of torture for such a purpose a punishable offence,
torture and ill-treatment of political detainees were widespread in recent
years. It reportedly emerged from testimony given by former detainees held
between 1986 and 1988 that a pattern of torture existed in the country and
that safeguards to protect detainees from being tortured were insufficient.
The methods of physical and psychological torture alleged to be resorted to in
Egyptian prisons in recent years were the following: suspension by the
wrists, ankles or knees; beating with cable, whips and thick sticks,
principally on the soles of the feet or on the top of the head; extinguishing
cigarettes on the body; electric shocks administered with wires or batons to
sensitive parts of the body such as the mouth, nipples or genitals; sexual
abuse and threats of being killed or imprisoned indefinitely, or of rape or
sexual abuBe, directed either at the detainee or at the detainee's relatives.
It was reported that numerous torture complaints had been filed in recent
years with the office of the Prosecutor General, but that no investigation
into such complaints was known to have taken place. The following cases of
alleged torture were reported:
(a) Hafez Al Sayyid Sa'ada, was arrested in early 1988 and held by the
State Security Intelligence police at Gaber Bin Hayyan Street in Doqqi for
more than two weeks, during which time he was allegedly severely tortured, to
the point that he had to be treated in hospital before being sent to Tora
Reception Prison;
(b) Magdi Gharib Fayed, Muhammad Taha Abdul Azim Al Beheiri, and
Farouq Al Sayyid Ashour, were arrested and charged with the attempted
assassination of former Interior Minister Major General Hassan Abu Basha in
May 1987. The three men were initially taken to the State Security
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents