E/CN.4/1990/17
page 23
(b) Cledanor Nonsant: Arrested in Leogane for unspecified reasons, he
was taken to the Faustin Soulouque barracks in Petit-Goave. He died in
hospital on 15 December 1988 after, according to the sources, he had been
severely beaten up by soldiers from Leogane and Petit-Goave;
(c) Ernest Louisdor: Arrested on 9 January 1989 by
Sergeant Frantz Florestal from the Petion-Ville garrison, who accused
him of being a thief. He was taken to the Carrefour military post, where
soldiers reportedly beat him all over the body and subjected him to
ill-treatment, including the "djak position". After being released,
Mr. Louisdor was taken to a hospital in Port-au-Prince and treated for
internal bleeding and other serious injuries. Sergeant Florestal is then
said to have threatened to kill Mr. Louisdor and his family.
75. On 2 January 1989 the Haitian Government addressed a letter to the
Special Rapporteur, citing a number of decrees and other measures adopted by
the Government since it had taken office on 17 September 1988, to ensure
respect for and promotion and protection of human rights. With reference to
the case of Mr. Ernest Louisdor, a memorandum dated 27 February 1989 from the
Police Headquarters in Port-au-Prince, annexed to the letter, stated that an
inquiry had been conducted into the affair and had revealed that Mr. Louisdor
was beaten by soldiers at the Carrefour Outpost, who said that they had done
so because he had refused to obey their orders. Disciplinary action has been
taken against them. The Haitian Ministry for Foreign Affairs had, for the
time being, no other information on the other two cases mentioned in the
letter.
76. On 13 November 1989 the Special Rapporteur addressed a letter to the
Haitian Government transmitting information that on 1 August 1989 members of
the police in Cap Haitien arrested Jean-Robert Lalanne, aged 28, a leading
member of the National People's Assembly (APN). Mr. Lalanne was reportedly
held without charges at the police station for 24 hours and severely tortured
during that time. According to Mr. Lalanne, the police chief, whose name was
transmitted to the Government, ordered six or seven policemen present to hit
Mr. Lalanne. He was tied up in the "djak" position and the policemen clubbed
him until he fainted. Later, a lieutenant, whose name was also transmitted to
the Government, is again said to have beaten him severely. The next morning,
he was taken to "Criminal Investigations", where seven policemen again
tortured him. Immediately after he was released, Mr. Lalanne had to be
hospitalized at the Hopital Justinien, where Dr. Gerard Lubin treated him.
In a medical certificate dated 4 August 1989 Dr. Lubin certified that
on 2 August 1989 he had examined Mr. Lalanne for multiple injuries as a result
of a beating by the police. The doctor found considerable inflammation and
swelling on both of the patient's buttocks and concluded that approximately
two months would be needed for surgery and medical attention.
77. On 20 November 1989 the Special Rapporteur sent an urgent message
to the Haitian Government stating that Mr. Jean Auguste Mesyeux,
a member of the Haitian Workers Independent Federation (CATH), Mr. Evans Paul
(alias Konge Plume), a member of KID, and Mr. Marino Etienne, a member
of the 17 September People's Organization (0P-17), were arrested
on 1 November 1989, apparently charged with conspiring against the
Government. On 2 November 1989 the three detainees were shown on television
and, according to the information received, it seemed obvious that they had
been severely ill-treated. The people guilty of this maltreatment were
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents