Assessing Damage, Urging Action
Foreword
Since 11 September 2001, countering terrorism has become one of the biggest priorities for many governments and for the international community. Terrorism is a real
threat in many parts of the world and States must address terrorism robustly and
effectively. However it is no less imperative that they do so through methods that do
not undermine the fundamental values at the heart of the international legal system.
It is regrettable that during the last eight years many States have responded to
terrorism in a manner that threatens the very core of the international human rights
framework, that represents perhaps one of the most serious challenges ever posed
to the integrity of a system carefully constructed after the Second World War.
In order to respond to this alarming trend, in 2004 the International Commission
of Jurists (ICJ) adopted the Berlin Declaration on Upholding Human Rights while
Combating Terrorism and called for the establishment of a high level panel mandated
to conduct a detailed study on the global impact of counter-terrorism measures on
human rights. In 2005 the Eminent Jurists Panel on Terrorism, Counter-Terrorism and
Human Rights was convened. This initiative follows in the footsteps of the ICJ’s long
tradition of critical work on human rights in times of crisis, reflected for example in
its 1983 study on “States of Emergency: Their Impact on Human Rights,” that was
carried out in response to the prevalence of states of emergencies during the 1970’s
and 1980’s.
The Panel, which is composed of eight distinguished jurists from all regions of
the world, is an independent body, supported by ICJ Secretariat staff. The Panel’s
report represents the culmination of an intense and in-depth inquiry over a period
of three years. The sixteen Hearings which the Panel held in different countries
throughout the world, and on which many of the report’s findings are based, have
been at the heart of this inquiry, and constitute one of the most comprehensive
surveys on counter-terrorism and human rights ever undertaken. Our gratitude to
the civil society organisations, human rights defenders and members of the legal
community worldwide that engaged in this process, and whose collaboration made
it possible, cannot be overstated. Our admiration for their unwavering commitment
to the protection of human rights, in the difficult environment that has prevailed
since 2001, is immense.
This report does not mark the end of ICJ work on this issue. Rather it represents the
beginning of a new chapter. As a global network of jurists the ICJ will now initiate
a programme of work intended to build on the Panel’s findings and recommendations. As the Panel highlights, cycles of terrorism and counter-terrorism invariably
continue over time. In this context it is vital that governments and the international
community now engage in a stock-taking process designed to ensure that respect for
human rights and the rule of law is integrated into every aspect of counter-terrorism
work. Several of the concerns identified by the Panel require urgent attention. These
include the expansion of intelligence agency powers and international cooperation
v