the Legal Aid Council (LAC) is still
pending. Some individual states have
established public defender bodies within
the Ministry of Justice to provide free legal
assistance to residents of the state, but
they often have limited capacity.
(f) The power to order or
approve arrest and
supervision of the police and
detention facilities should be
vested solely with
independent courts
Police functions to arrest, detain
and investigate suspects for
offences were vested in a
myriad of law enforcement
agencies. Time limits and
safeguards regarding
imprisonment were frequently
not complied with, as the
Special Rapporteur found that
people were sometimes detained
for months under police arrest.
Non-governmental sources: No action has
been taken toward implementing this
recommendation.
(g) All detainees should be
effectively guaranteed the
ability to challenge the
lawfulness of the detention
before an independent court,
e.g. through habeas corpus
proceedings
De facto, the vast majority of
detainees did not have the
ability to challenge the
lawfulness of their detention
due to the lack of financial
means, the overload of the
entire judicial system as well as
a climate of fear.
Non-governmental sources: A detainee’s
power to challenge their detention is
dependent on their financial capacity, and
poverty restricts the ability of detainees to
obtain adequate legal representation.
(h) Judges and prosecutors
should routinely ask persons
brought from police custody
how they have been treated
and, even in the absence of a
formal complaint from the
defendant, order an
independent medical
examination in accordance
with the Istanbul Protocol
While in principle empowered
to do so, judges and prosecutors
did not ex-officio enquire about
potential torture and illtreatment in police custody.
Non-governmental sources: Judges and
prosecutors do not routinely ask detainees
how they have been treated.
(i) Those legally arrested
should not be held in
While legal provisions foresaw
that persons arrested or detained
Forensic medical examinations
which could sustain complaints
were non-existent, even in cases
of death in police custody.
Non-governmental sources: Following an
amendment to the Magistrate Court Law
A/HRC/13/39/Add.6
135
vast majority of detainees did
not have legal counsel.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents