92
provoke unwanted contacts
of those serving sentences
(UK 161/1 in Kostanay). In
some cells, the rules of privacy
are not respected (AP-162/1
in Pavlodar).
Prisoners’ prolonged stay
in the above conditions can
be described as torture,
humiliation of human dignity
and cruel treatment of
prisoners.
Recommendations:
All Departments of the
penitentiary system and the
Committee of the penitentiary
system MIA RoK should make
efforts to eliminate all the
above mentioned issues.
Medical services
Conclusions:
In
recent
years, NPM members have
noted serious issues in the
medical care of individuals
detained
in
pre-trial
detention centers. They are
connected to the insufficient
staffing of the medical
wards, inadequate medical
care, and subordination of
the medical wards to the
pre-trial detention center
administration. The latter
creates conditions for the
CONSOLIDATED REPORT
physical
violence
from
administration, either directly
or with the help of other
prisoners, with persons who
reasonably and consistently
defend their rights and
legitimate
interests
and
who wish to achieve justice
in higher and supervisory
bodies. Dependent doctors
cannot give an objective
conclusion on the physical
condition
of
persons
subjected to violence from
the administration. As a
result, during special visits
NPM members could only
state torture and physical
abuse, according to the
words of victims, due to the
lack of a doctor’s opinion
at the time of the incident.
Subsequently, when the facts
of ill-treatment are registered
by the relevant authorities to
investigate and punish the
perpetrators, the case again
rests on the absence of a
doctor’s opinion on the fact
of violence. Thus, the guilty
persons escape responsibility
for torture and ill-treatment
of prisoners.
The main issue is the
transfer of the medical
service in pre-trial detention
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents