Annual Report 2012: Spain’s National Preventive Mechanism
consent, when there exists «a serious immediate risk for the patient’s physical or
psychological integrity and his/her consent cannot be obtained»; however, there
is no specific mention or reference to physical or pharmacological restraints.
Nonetheless, the Social Services laws of some autonomous regions do establish
the right of users of Social Services to not be subjected to any kind of immobiliza
tion or physical and pharmacological restraint without a medical prescription
and supervision, unless there exists imminent danger for the user’s physical safe
ty and that of third parties. As a safeguard for users, these laws require docu
mented justification for said actions, that they be recorded in the user’s file and
that the Public Prosecutor’s Office be notified.
The use of physical and
In consequence, it is essential to clearly and concisely regulate the concept of
pharmacological restraints
restraint at a national level, together with the cases in which restraint can be
must be regulated in a clear
and precise manner
applied, proportionality and suitability of the means used, the time the
measure is to last, authorization for application of the measure, documenta
tion of measures taken, assessment of the effects and results, and all necessary
guarantees.
Residential centers must
aim at reducing the use of
restraints
199. Moreover, centers should aim at reducing the use of restraints. This could
be achieved, for example, by encouraging residents to move around with mobili
zation and «fitness walking» programs to prevent loss of mobility, or by means of
greater control by the assistant nursing staff to prevent falls. Likewise, the use of
restraints that only limit a patient’s mobility to the extent required should be
given priority (for example, non-skid harnesses instead of belts).
The Protocol on the use of
During the inspection visit it was noted that in general terms the «San José» Res
restraints must be updated
idence tried to minimize the use of restraint and to use them in any case follow
to unify guidelines and
ensure that the rights of
ing medical criteria, and not as punishment. The physician asks the relatives to
individual residents are
authorize the measure in writing and fills out the form prescribing restraint,
guaranteed at all times
which is not subsequently modified or updated if the conditions that motivated
immobilization do not change. The physician prescribes physical restraint and
day to day application is carried out by the nursing staff following the medical
order. Even though use of restraints is and subject to strict medical criteria of the
physician in charge in each building, the medical personnel interviewed ac
knowledged that some of the restraints could be avoided by having more assistant
nursing staff and with mobilization and walking programs. The center’s manage
ment should update the «Protocol on the Use of Restraints» in order to unify
guidelines in this matter, subject at all times to guarantees for the rights of indi
vidual residents.
146
THE OMBUDSMAN OF SPAIN
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents