Annual Report 2012: Spain’s National Preventive Mechanism
with the efficacy of the work performed by the health services, and finally, inmates whose medical checkup was expressly requested by the technicians from
the Ombudsman Institution carrying out the visit.
An investigation has been
carried out on the
treatment provided to
inmates who have
denounced ill-treatment by
police officers
Those inmates who
complained of
ill-treatment were
physically examined
Individual and group
interviews have been held
with the inmates
The existing recordings
were viewed, in order to
check if complaints sent by
inmates were true
68
48. During these multidisciplinary visits, an investigation was carried out on
the treatment provided to those inmates who had been tried to be deported with
out success, taking into account the complaints received at this Institution de
nouncing that the interested persons had been the subject of alleged ill-treatment
by the police. In the cases examined at the CIEs of Madrid and Valencia, inter
views were held with inmates who were still interned and clinical histories were
reviewed, but it was not possible to conclude, either because of the data included
in those histories or due to the declarations of the interested persons themselves,
that there had been any ill-treatment by police officers.
At the Immigration Detention Centers visited, some inmates complained that
they had been subject to ill-treatment. In those cases, in addition to viewing any
recordings that may exist in this respect, physical exams of those involved were
carried out by the external technical expert, subsequently reporting such actions
to the relevant Department of the Ombudsman Institution so that it may assess
the possibility of opening the appropriate investigation.
49. During the visits to the CIEs, besides the personal interviews held with some
inmates, group interviews were also held with some inmates, who were given
questionnaires regarding the prison regime and the treatment they received.
Many of them declared that the rules of the center were not clear and were not
respected; some of them declared that they felt unsafe at the center, in case of
risks of illness or fire, as well as due to the treatment by certain officers or other
inmates; as regards the means of restraint, the majority declared that isolation
(temporal separation) was used for almost any reason; many considered that strip
searches were humiliating, although the vast majority declared that they were
conducted in a private place and that room searches were frequent and without
their presence, not knowing if the officers needed authorization to carry them
out; they also complained of the food, as well as the water temperature and the
furniture.
50. In relation to the personal or room searches, during the visit to the CIE in
Valencia the existing recordings were viewed in order to assess if the complaints
of inmates on personal searches -where they declared that they were told to un
dress upon being admitted at the center- and the complaints on room searches
-where they said those were conducted every day-, were true or not. From the
results of the investigation it may be concluded that the viewed searches were
superficial, and only one case was detected where an inmate brought down his
trousers a little bit. As regards the daily search of rooms, it was noticed that, in
deed, when inmates left their rooms, the officers entered into them and remained
inside only for a few seconds in order to check, as was reported, that all inmates
had left.
THE OMBUDSMAN OF SPAIN
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents