Medium-term Deprivation of Liberty
the Police declared it was working to set up a switchboard. At the CIE in Algeci
ras no calls were allowed from the outside, and the Directorate General of the
Police reported in this regard that a specific and personal service would be addi
tionally needed, both for safety and to receive calls. As regards the CIE of Valen
cia, inmates complained that, except the phone cards provided by family or
friends, they had to buy them from the kitchen staff, which entailed an “extra
charge”, as they said, for these cards and, besides, if they didn’t have the exact
amount, they were told they had no change, which in some cases resulted in their
paying a lot more for these cards. The Directorate General of the Police has re
ported that there is no record of the charge of commissions and that the supply of
such cards would be solved with the arrival of the social workers included in the
future regulation of the CIEs.
67. As regards the lack of recreational material referred to in paragraphs 271 of
the 2010 Annual Report and 103 of the 2011 Annual Report, the Directorate Gen
eral of the Police has informed that the inmates themselves are the ones who
sometimes spoil the material provided to them and that, given the lack of a budg
et for this concept, they depend on the material donated by NGOs, companies or
even officers themselves. This shortage has been the subject of complaints from
inmates of the CIEs in Algeciras and Valencia; specifically from the latter, regard
ing the lack of sports material, such as balls for play in the courtyard. Notwith
standing the reply sent by the Directorate General of the Police, during the visits
undertaken to the CIEs in Tarifa (2010), Santa Cruz de Tenerife (2011) and Barce
lona (2012), the Ombudsman Institution was able to verify that these centers had
adequate material, and no inappropriate use thereof was referred to by the per
sons in charge of the centers.
There is no budget
68. In relation to other shortcomings identified at the visited centers, such as the
lack of a washer and dryer, or of shower screens at the CIE in Valencia, the re
placement of impaired mattresses at the CIE in Madrid or to partially cover the
courtyards in Algeciras and Valencia, the Directorate General of the Police has
adduced the lack of budget to carry out the necessary works or acquisitions.
However, in the case of the courtyard at the women’s area of the CIE in Algeciras,
given the general disrepair thereof, the Directorate General of the Police has re
ported that it would proceed to adequately repair it. In a similar vein, in the spe
cific case of the visitation room at the CIE in Valencia, it has been reformed after
the visit of this Institution. It now has a parlor/independent room and another
two separated by a partition, which offer more privacy while ensuring safety.
In spite of the lack of a
69. The Directorate General of the Police has reported that in November 2012 it
started the construction to repair the drainage collection systems located in the
semibasement of the CIE in Valencia, in order to remove the bad smells which
affected the office area, as was referred to in paragraphs 254 of the 2010 Annual
Report and 105 of the 2011 Annual Report.
At the CIE in Valencia,
THE OMBUDSMAN OF SPAIN
for recreational
material
budget to carry out
construction, the visitation
room at the CIE in Valencia
has been reformed and the
courtyard at the women’s
area of the CIE in Algeciras
has been repaired
construction have
started to remedy the
shortcomings pointed
out in 2010 and 2011
73
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents