JEAN-JACQUES GAUTIER NPM SYMPOSIUM 2016
however, the staff are willing to share their doubts and discuss the
constraints in their working conditions. The monitoring mandate and
the aims of the visits must be clearly explained so that the staff view
the NPM’s observations as a valuable contribution to improve the
running of the establishment, including the staff conditions – one of
the aspects that the NPM is required to observe. In many cases, the
NPMs acknowledged that the use of methods violating the integrity
of the individuals was in part the result of staff shortages and a lack
of appropriate staff training.
“The inspectors have met teams who are equally concerned
about the rights of patients and ask questions about how to
treat them humanely. They query the merit of using seclusion
and are open to discussion on their practices but are short of
time and take these practices for granted. They say that in the
beginning they were shocked, but now they no longer think
about it.”
Anne Lecourbe, NPM, France
Private interviews with the users
The NPMs highlighted the importance of having private interviews
with many persons placed in psychiatric institutions, as well as
taking all the necessary precautions to maintain their anonymity
and prevent the risk of reprisals. However, as part of each visit
and depending on the establishment’s specific characteristics, it is
important that the NPMs draft selection criteria for these private
interviews. During the Symposium, the NPMs identified the following
selection criteria: meeting people who would like to see the NPM but
also those who have just been admitted to the institution, will soon
be leaving it, are or have been in seclusion, as well as persons in
particular situation of vulnerability (e.g. children, the elderly).
Meeting users who are under physical restraint raises ethical
questions. Indeed, these persons are in a particularly vulnerable and
degrading situation and having an unknown person visiting them
can be an added humiliation. The CPT shared their experience on
this matter by underlining the importance of meeting these people
regardless, if they consent to it, since the aim of the meeting is to
36
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents