MONITORING PSYCHIATRIC INSTITUTIONS
is therefore essential for visiting teams to take the time, at the start
of each visit, to explain why they are there, what they will be doing
and to break down this initial resistance.
Towards a paradigm shift: the Convention on the
Rights of Persons with Disabilities
For a long time, an exclusively medical approach to mental disability
has prevailed and psychiatrists’ opinions have never or rarely been
questioned. This situation has led to the wishes of persons with
mental disabilities being ignored as they were, and in practice still
are, considered “incapable” of making independent decisions. The
participants mentioned that there is a power game behind the
medical community’s reticence to be supervised by independent
bodies protecting human rights, such as the NPMs, as the psychiatric
body has a “monopoly” on care and, in some cases, has also been
entrusted by the government authorities with the mission of “social
control”.
In many countries, this power is compounded by stigmatisation and
discrimination towards persons with mental disabilities in a society
that tends to accept the incarceration of persons who are assumed to
be dangerous. The place and role of families in institutionalisation is
an issue that was raised several times during the Symposium. Social
stigma, as well as the absence of support and suitable structures
in the community, contribute to families “abandoning” a relative
with a disability in closed institutions. This situation is particularly
serious in societies with strong superstitions, and in which families
use traditional healers who offer treatments that can present serious
risks to a person’s physical and mental integrity and are not subject
to any outside inspection. Nevertheless, it was pointed out that, in
certain countries, such as Senegal, the family plays an integral role
in the care, ensuring more compassionate treatment and a more
humane environment, as well as an easier return to society following
hospitalisation and thus avoiding a long-term separation from life in
the community.
Based on these findings and traditional discrimination towards
persons with mental disabilities, the Symposium’s participants
acknowledged the need for a change in their approach to accepting
these individuals as subjects of rights and not as ”objects” of medical
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents