JEAN-JACQUES GAUTIER NPM SYMPOSIUM 2016
as to a lack of training on de-escalation techniques for managing
agitation. Reference was therefore made to the importance of NPMs’
role in identifying situations liable to result in crises, such as: lack of
access to carers, lack of activities, limited visitor access, few or no
opportunities to smoke.
“I always remember the story of a young man, who admitted
himself to hospital. He felt he needed support. He came
voluntarily and he was administered medication immediately.
He was given a drug before he had talked to anyone. The drug
caused him to have involuntary movements. That behaviour
was then recognised as agitation when he was simply trying to
communicate. After that, he was given an injection and he then
lost the ability to speak and was perceived as not consenting
to treatment, so they started treating him involuntarily by
restraining him on the bed.”
Dragana Ćirić, Mental Disability Rights Initiative, Serbia
The NPMs and other experts who were present questioned what
approach should be adopted in these circumstances. While some
advocated better training (for example, giving written instructions
to professionals) and more control of these practices to provide
greater safeguards for users, others stated that the only approach
that ensures human rights are respected is to prohibit these
practices, as recommended by the UN Committee on the Rights of
Persons with Disabilities.
Dignity and respect for the right to privacy
Living conditions in psychiatric institutions and the restrictions
imposed on persons who are hospitalised also affect the protection
and respect for their right to privacy. Situations that were identified
often included a total absence of privacy: being unable to lock their
room’s door (provided that such private rooms exist) and to keep
one’s personal belongings including one’s own clothes. There is
often an obligation to wear pyjamas for alleged safety reasons: to
stop individuals from running away. Access to a mobile phone can
also be restricted or even prohibited throughout the duration of the
26
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents