Psychological examinations within asylum procedures
35
Psychological examinations within
asylum procedures
Many asylum seekers suffer from health problems arising
from their flight and the violence that preceded it. Most often
these are physical problems related to pain and experiences
of violence and mental problems such as depression, anxiety
and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Research on Iraqi
asylum seekers, for example, showed a high incidence of psychiatric illness (42%) among asylum seekers that recently
arrived in the Netherlands.1 Of this group, one quarter suffered
from depression and approximately another third from PTSD.
Also, in some cases, asylum seekers will remain silent about
what happened in order to protect themselves against painful
memories, or they may find it indecent to talk about the events
because it is culturally inappropriate to do so. It is clear that
most of these problems existed during the asylum interviews
and that they interfere with the outcomes of those hearings,
resulting often in a questionable rejection of the application
for asylum.
Medical and psychological research in the field of traumatisation indicates that trauma can cause interference with
memory and incapacity to recall events. As a consequence,
some asylum seekers are unable to give a complete and coherent account of their flight. The story the asylum seeker tells
to the immigration authorities during the interview is pivotal,
frequently making the difference between a residence permit
and expulsion.
The accelerated asylum procedure (“fast track”) in The
Netherlands has been criticised (i.e. by Human Rights Watch,
the UN High Commissioner for Refugees and Committee
against Torture) because of the lack of adequate guarantees for
a fair consideration of asylum claims of vulnerable individuals, including asylum seekers with mental health problems.
But also in the “regular” (non-accelerated) procedure, physical scars, medical and psychological complaints as well as accompanying behavioural and socio-cultural problems are not
By Erick Vloeberghs MSc, international affairs, Pharos; Evert Bloemen
MD, senior advisor/trainer, Pharos;
and Riëtte Mellink MA, psychologist/psychotherapist and one of the
initiators of the MAPP project
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents