Yet, although the use of solitary confinement on a large scale ceased, it remained an integral
part of prison systems and, as previously noted, in the last decade its use has increased in many
jurisdictions. Throughout the decades researchers have continued to report negative effects
associated with solitary confinement, and their findings are strikingly similar to those made by their
historic counterparts.
Contemporary findings
More recent studies have mostly reaffirmed that solitary confinement adversely affects those
subjected to it, and have identified “confinement psychosis” as a medical condition typified by
“psychotic reaction characterised frequently by hallucinations and delusions, produced by prolonged
physical isolation and inactivity in completely segregated areas” (Scott & Gendreau, 1969:338).
A 1975 inquiry into the use of isolation in Canadian prisons concluded that administrative isolation
over long periods of time represented a “serious danger for prisoners”22. Two years later a Council
of Europe (1977) study suggested that prolonged close-confinement of long-term prisoners led
to what was termed ‘separation syndrome’ that included emotional, cognitive, social and physical
problems23. Benjamin & Lux (1977:262) stated that “evidence overwhelmingly [indicates] that solitary
confinement alone, even in the absence of physical brutality or unhygienic conditions, can produce
emotional damage, decline in mental functioning and even the most extreme forms of psychopathology
such as depersonalization, hallucinations and delusions”. Ruling in a case involving prisoners held in
strict isolation in Germany, the European Human Rights Commission (1978:97) similarly noted that
“isolation can be sufficient in itself to gravely impair physical and mental health”.
Grassian’s (1983) psychiatric evaluation of 14 prisoners held in the solitary confinement block at the
Massachusetts Correctional Institution at Walpole reported perceptual changes, affective disturbances,
difficulty with thinking, concentration and memory, disturbances of thought content, and problems
with impulse control. Korn’s study (1988) of the women’s High Security Unit at Lexington, Kentucky,
found that women held there suffered claustrophobia, rage, severe depression, hallucinations,
withdrawal, blunting of affect and apathy. He also reported appetite loss, weight loss, visual
disturbances and heart palpitations. Brodsky & Scogin’s (1988) study of 45 prisoners held in protective
custody similarly reported a high prevalence of negative physiological and psychological symptoms
including nervousness, talking to oneself, hallucinations and delusions, confusion, irrational anger,
headaches and problems sleeping. Hodgins & Cote (1991) found severe mental disorders amongst 29
per cent of a sample of 41 segregated prisoners held in Quebec’s Special Handling Unit (SHU), and in
31 per cent of a sample of 32 prisoners segregated in the Long-Term Segregation Unit (LTSU)24.
Haney’s (1993) study of 100 randomly selected prisoners in one of California’s supermax prisons,
Pelican Bay Security Housing Unit, reported a very high prevalence of symptoms of psychological
trauma with 91% of the prisoners sampled suffering from anxiety and nervousness, more than 80%
suffering from headaches, lethargy and trouble sleeping and 70% fearing impending breakdown.
More than half of the prisoners suffered from nightmares, dizziness and heart palpitations and
other mental-health problems caused by isolation, which included ruminations, irrational anger
and confused thought processes (more than 80% of prisoners sampled), chronic depression (77%),
hallucinations (41%) and overall deterioration.
Sourcebook on solitary confinement: The health effects of solitary confinement
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents